Advisory Opinions In Dicta We Trust
10 snips
Nov 19, 2024 Prepare for a wild ride through legal controversies! The hosts tackle the chaos surrounding Matt Gaetz’s potential appointment and delve into the intricacies of Supreme Court nominations. They raise questions about gender identity, free speech in schools, and the implications of student expression. Listeners will hear about the humorous side of handling criticism and the role of engagement rings in society. Plus, insights from a Federalist Society convention set the tone for lively political discourse!
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Evaluating Appointments
- Consider the broader context when evaluating political appointments, not just personal preferences.
- Think about potential downsides of rejecting a nominee like Matt Gaetz.
Responding with Grace
- Approach disagreements with civility and respect, avoiding personal attacks.
- Focus on the issue at hand rather than making broad judgments.
Categorical Approach
- The Supreme Court uses a categorical approach, focusing on statutory elements not specific facts.
- This approach creates complexities, as seen in the Delgati case about crime of violence.