The Catholic Talk Show History Has Lied About Catholics
10 snips
Oct 13, 2025 Explore the complex legacies of historical figures like Columbus and the Crusaders. Delve into the debate: hero or villain? Discover how propaganda shaped perceptions of the Black Legend. Uncover the truth behind Galileo's story and the manipulation of historical narratives. Learn about the importance of context in evaluating past events and figures. The hosts emphasize the need for careful discernment and love in understanding history, urging listeners to question sensationalized accounts and view history through a nuanced lens.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Columbus's Reputation Is Oversimplified
- Christopher Columbus's modern vilification ignores his own writings that show he forbade mistreatment and sought conversion.
- Ryan Scheel argues disease and later actions, not Columbus alone, caused Indigenous population collapse.
Conversion Sparked By Columbus Research
- A local researcher studying Columbus convinced himself of Catholicism after reading Columbus's writings.
- Ryan DellaCrosse recounts that discovery while discussing a statue controversy in a U.S. town.
Judge Figures By Their Own Context
- Historical judgement shifts with the mood of the age and lacks context when applied retroactively.
- Ryan Scheel warns modern standards make it easy to misjudge figures like Columbus unfairly.
