Brain in a Vat Don't Vote | Chris Freiman with Rebecca Tuvel
Feb 17, 2025
Chris Freiman, author of "Why It's Okay to Ignore Politics," champions the idea that ignoring politics can be justified, using thought experiments to tackle objections. He discusses charity versus civic duty, ranking altruistic actions above voting. Philosophical insights from Rebecca Tuvel highlight moral complexities in helping others versus participating in elections. Together, they debate effective altruism and the ethics of individual impact, all while questioning our obligations to future generations and the trustworthiness of charities.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Child's Sight vs. Vote
- On election day, imagine seeing a child with a serious eye injury while driving to the polls.
- You should prioritize saving the child's sight over voting, even if it means missing your vote.
Donate Instead of Voting
- Instead of voting, work extra hours and donate your earnings to effective charities.
- The opportunity cost of voting, even in ordinary circumstances, could be significant, like saving a child's sight.
Political Participation vs. Other Good Deeds
- Political participation is not uniquely virtuous compared to other forms of good deeds.
- Volunteering at a hospital or fire department is arguably as good or better than voting.