Dror Bar Natan, a Professor of pure mathematics at the University of Toronto, specializes in knot theory and quantum field theory. He explores the intricate connections between knot theory and particle dynamics, revealing surprising parallels that challenge traditional perceptions. With humor, he shares insights on academic life, the importance of effective teaching, and innovative approaches that prioritize understanding over rote memorization. Additionally, Dror reflects on the complexities of talent in mathematics and the fascinating application of knot theory to biological structures.
02:55:01
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
QFT and Knot Theory
Quantum field theory and knot theory are surprisingly related, as both involve particle interactions like creation and annihilation.
Knot theory studies particle dances in lower dimensions, mirroring QFT's focus on particle behavior.
insights INSIGHT
Indirect Link Between QFT and Topology
Quantum field theory's techniques for infinite-dimensional integrals are useful in topology, indirectly connecting the two fields.
Topology uses these integrals to compute quantities associated with knots, rather than just individual curves.
question_answer ANECDOTE
Knots vs. Curves
Dror Bar-Natan explains how integrating over all geometries helps distinguish knots, not just curves.
He mentions Chern-Simons theory as a complex example using QFT techniques in knot theory.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
LINKS MENTIONED:
PDF link of notes: https://tinyurl.com/4u4ru2yh
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00:00 Introduction
00:03:29 Quantum Field Theory and Knot Theory
00:10:19 Another QFT / Knot Theory connection or analogy
00:20:46 Knot Theory and Gravity + Bar-Natan's PhD on Chern-Simons
00:24:08 Homology and Cohomology
00:32:54 Dror's average day / routines / laziness
00:35:23 What is "work" for a Professor? How much of it is thinking vs. reading etc.?
00:36:50 All the research is to support teaching
00:41:34 Motivated examples are what's missing in math teaching
00:47:35 Are you more creative when younger or older?
00:48:43 Being "systematic" with learning and research
00:50:37 Rant against theorems and proofs (emphasis)
00:54:51 What understanding a mathematical concept looks like
01:03:35 On laziness, strengths, and weaknesses in mathematics
01:07:47 Advice for the struggling mathematician
01:09:30 What did Dror learn from studying with Ed Witten
01:12:12 On Eric Weinstein
01:19:32 Knot Theory and Physics (again)
01:20:10 Why can't physics of 2 or 3 dimensions be extended to 4 easily?
01:34:21 Hard Problem of Consciousness
01:35:54 The problems Dror thinks about daily
01:37:49 What direction would he like mathematics research to head in?
01:40:26 Philosophy of math (ultra-finitism)
01:44:45 Pure mathematics in service to applied mathematics
01:47:14 How to learn a new field of mathematics
01:47:15 [the scientific mystical philosopher] Unreasonable effectiveness of mathematics
01:48:28 [Romain Gicquad] On IQ
01:51:06 [Tori Ko] What do you think about biology / psychology / philosophy
01:54:03 [Phill Thomas] What led him into the field of mathematics? Can anyone can learn advanced math?
02:03:52 [Tyler Goldstein] Do we need to make new research institutions not linked to academia?
02:06:04 Bias in academia
02:10:15 What's a mathematician? Who's a mathematician and who's not?
02:14:31 [Ashley Shipp] Does he think there is a connection between knot theory and protein folding?
02:19:49 [Jack Dysart] Is math a human construct?
02:22:50 [cx777o] Does he believe in a concept of god?
05:19:49 [Bill McGonigle] Ramanujan and his Goddess
02:23:47 Revealed story that Dror has about Curt and the Prisoner's Dilemma
02:30:27 [Harinivas P] Bible Code and applying advanced math in one's life
02:37:26 [Roy Dopson] Why does it take 360 pages to "prove" that 1+1=2?
* * *
Just wrapped (April 2021) a documentary called Better Left Unsaid http://betterleftunsaidfilm.com on the topic of "when does the left go too far?" Visit that site if you'd like to watch it.