
Calmversations s08e14 | From Libertarian to Post-Liberal, with Brandon Harnish
Oct 31, 2025
Brandon Harnish, an Indiana local politician and conservative commentator, shares his intriguing journey from a libertarian youth to a post-liberal Catholic outlook. He discusses the tensions between libertarianism and conservatism at the local level and how the debates around transgenderism prompted a significant spiritual shift. Brandon emphasizes the importance of tradition and local institutions, critiquing the pitfalls of free market logic in small towns. He advocates for building community bonds and mentoring young activists to revitalize local politics.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Libertarianism's Hidden Assumptions
- Brandon observes American libertarianism contains contradictions: extreme individualism rests on assumed social norms.
- He realized pure individualism lacks coherence without embedded social institutions.
Trans Issues Sparked A Religious Shift
- Transgenderism triggered Brandon's theological crisis and led him to Catholicism via RCIA in 2024.
- He found Catholic theology of the body gave a stronger account of sex, gender, and embodied sacramentality.
2020 Revealed The State As A Weapon
- COVID and 2020 revealed to Brandon that the state can be an active instrument used against communities.
- That realization pivoted him from anarcho-capitalism toward engaging with state power through the Republican Party.









