In this conversation, EdUp Provost host Dr. Gregor Thuswaldner and Dr. Eboo Patel discuss the critical role of pluralism in higher education, emphasizing its importance in fostering a diverse and inclusive academic environment. Dr. Patel outlines the various dimensions of pluralism, including identity, value, and agonistic pluralism, and argues for the necessity of humility in intellectual discourse. He also addresses the challenges of navigating controversial topics on campus, the need for effective crisis management, and the importance of integrating pluralism into the curriculum. Dr. Patel advocates for the establishment of pluralism centers within universities and highlights the essential skills needed for students to engage constructively with ideological and religious diversity. Takeaways • Pluralism should be the defining paradigm of a university. • Universities play a crucial role in fostering identity pluralism. • Intellectual humility is essential for effective pluralism. • Disagreement is inherent in a diverse democracy. • Constructive engagement is key to navigating campus controversies.