In this enlightening discussion, guests include Shashank Joshi, a defense expert; Edward Carr, a global economics analyst; Arkady Ostrovsky, a specialist in Russian politics; and Sarah Larniuk, who reports directly from Ukraine. They delve into the stagnation in the Ukraine war and the growing use of surveillance and drones. The harsh realities faced by soldiers and civilians are explored, highlighting deeper morale issues. The conversation emphasizes the complex interplay of international support, Ukrainian resilience, and the human cost of ongoing conflict.
Ukraine's war shows stalemate in territorial gains due to increased intelligence and firepower challenges.
Morale decline in Ukrainian forces signifies exhaustion and hopelessness amidst prolonged conflict.
Deep dives
Summary of Ukraine's War Situation
The war in Ukraine, now two years old, has resulted in a lack of significant territorial gains due to stalemate on the front lines. Both sides face challenges in advancing due to increased intelligence and firepower. Notable changes have occurred in sea warfare, where Ukraine has seen successes. The shift towards fixed lines and mass armor favors Russia, posing challenges for Ukraine's mobile and inventive early tactics.
Impact of Morale on Ukrainian Forces
Morale among Ukrainian forces has significantly declined over the two-year war period. Soldiers and civilians alike face exhaustion and a sense of hopelessness. The prolonged conflict has led to decreasing motivation, with soldiers resorting to desperate measures to leave military service. The loss of key territories and the intensity of the war contribute to the overall decline in morale.
Discussion on Russian Offensive and Ukrainian Defenses
Despite Russia's continued military operations, significant territorial gains remain unlikely without robust foreign support. Western officials highlight a lack of trained officers and ammunition production in the Russian military. The focus on the campaign of deep strikes and Ukraine's ability to resist Russian advances and maintain political stability is crucial.
Challenges and Prospects for the Future
The future prospects of the war hinge on the ability of both Ukraine and Russia to endure the economic, social, and political pressures. The war's impact on society and economies on both sides will be a critical factor. While Russia may gain momentum in the short term, Ukraine's resilience and international support could shift the balance in the long run.
In this roundtable discussion our editors examine how the past year has progressed, discuss how things may go over the next year and consider a few fundamentally positive truths about the whole conflict. Meanwhile our senior producer travels through Ukraine, getting a measure of both determination and despondency among soldiers and civilians.
If you’re already a subscriber to The Economist, you’ll have full access to all our shows as part of your subscription. For more information about how to access Economist Podcasts+, please visit our FAQs page or watch our video explaining how to link your account.