
The Free Will Show Episode 112: Divine Luck with Andre Leo Rusavuk
Feb 2, 2026
Andre Rusavuk, a philosopher studying luck and religion, explores whether God can be subject to kinds of luck. He talks about present luck, libertarian freedom, and analogies that challenge divine immunity. He distinguishes constitutive and indirect luck and considers theological responses to these puzzles.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
How The Project Began
- Andre Rusavuk first got interested in luck by reading Bob Hartman's work on moral luck and was surprised he hadn't seen the problem applied to God.
- He then wrote his dissertation exploring whether the greatest possible being could be subject to various kinds of luck.
Perfect Immunity Thesis Defined
- Rusavuk defines God as the greatest possible being bearing the maximal set of compatible perfections.
- He frames the perfect immunity thesis: necessarily, God is perfectly immune to luck, and treats this as the central question.
Control As A Great-Making Property
- Rusavuk argues control is a great-making property and that luck diminishes control, so luck would be an imperfection.
- Therefore many theists intuitively think a greatest possible being should be immune to luck.



