Promise, Gift, and Postmodern Theology... oh and the Hobbit with Gregory Walter
Jan 14, 2014
auto_awesome
In this lively discussion, Gregory Walter, a professor at St. Olaf and author of 'Being Promised,' delves into the rich intersections of theology and literature. He explores Luther's law and grace through a postmodern lens, emphasizing the transformative power of promises and gifts. With a few detours, they geek out over 'The Hobbit,' dissecting its theological implications and cinematic adaptations. This fun blend of philosophy, practice, and Tolkien's legacy makes for a captivating conversation that encourages deeper faith engagement.
The podcast emphasizes the transformative power of promise within Luther's theology, illustrating its dynamic relationship with law and grace.
Gregory Walter's integration of philosophical perspectives, particularly Derrida, enriches the understanding of promise as a relational gift in theological discourse.
The discussion highlights the ethical implications of the concept of gift, particularly in practices like the Eucharist, emphasizing communal responsibility and hospitality.
Deep dives
Overview of 2013 Insights
The discussion reflects on the notable events and theological highlights of 2013, showcasing a multitude of live events and theological discussions that took place over the year. The hosts emphasize the significance of these occurrences by humorously recognizing their limited math skills, joking about how theologians usually count donations or baptisms rather than events. They outline how the cumulative experiences of the year shaped their understanding and contribution to the broader conversation in theology. Additionally, they highlight the most important theological themes discussed and celebrate the community involvement that characterized their efforts throughout the year.
The Importance of Promise in Theology
A significant portion of the conversation revolves around the theme of promise as framed by Martin Luther’s theology, particularly distinguishing it from law. The hosts explain that law serves not to condemn but instead to clarify and guide perception, much like glasses bring reality into focus. They emphasize that the relationship between law and gospel is not simply a dichotomy of bad versus good but a dynamic interplay that reveals grace's transformative power. This understanding of promise encourages listeners to embrace a more nuanced view of theology, recognizing the depth and relational nature of God's engagement with humanity.
Connection Between Gift and Promise
The dialogue explores the interconnectedness of the notions of gift and promise, emphasizing how promise functions as a gift that unfolds over time. The hosts introduce various philosophical perspectives to frame this discussion, highlighting a transition from traditional notions of law to a focus on relational and phenomenological aspects in understanding promise. Notably, the conversation integrates insights from thinkers like Derrida, who articulate the complexity of promise while connecting it to ethical practices and everyday life. This synthesis brings forth the idea that recognizing promise as a gift enriches both personal faith practices and community interactions.
Understanding Post-Foundationalist Theology
The podcast touches on the implications of post-foundationalism in theological discourse, suggesting that promise allows theology to function without relying on indubitable foundations. The hosts argue that theology rooted in promise accommodates uncertainty and risk, fostering a more adaptable and innovative approach to understanding God's nature. Engaging with various theological figures and modern criticisms, they assert that this shift illuminates the dynamic quality of God’s relationship with humanity. Ultimately, this reframing helps to bridge traditional theological understandings with contemporary thought, creating space for ongoing conversation and exploration.
Implications of Gift for Ethics and Practice
A critical aspect of the conversation is the implication of gift for ethical practices within the Christian tradition, particularly regarding community interactions. The hosts urge listeners to consider how the concept of gift informs broader ethical responsibilities, leading to tangible changes in practice and understanding. In particular, they highlight the Eucharist as an embodiment of promise and gift, where hospitality plays a critical role in communal experience. This exploration encourages communities to reflect deeply on their practices and the relational dynamics that underpin how they engage with both members and outsiders, challenging them to live out their theology in meaningful ways.
I had a HUGE blast talking with Dr. Walter. When you get to talk about a book you enjoyed, get side tracked on Jungel, and discuss the Hobbit it's called a podcast victory! I can't wait for his next visit to Homebrewed.
