The Future is Always Worse Than You Think | Andrew Willard Jones
Jan 16, 2025
auto_awesome
In this insightful discussion, Andrew Willard Jones, a prominent speaker at the 2024 New Polity Conference, delves into the oft-overlooked downsides of technological advancements. He argues that our dreams of a glorious future may lead to disappointment and disenchantment. Topics include the contrast between craftsmanship and technocracy, the evolution of warfare, and the profound relationship between art and humanity. Jones emphasizes the urgent need for human connection and the reclamation of humane values in a world increasingly dominated by mechanistic thinking.
The speaker argues that societal decline is reflected in dystopian literature and media, indicating that our future often disappoints expectations.
Contrasting craftsmanship with technocracy, he highlights how mechanization erodes relational understanding, replacing meaningful interactions with efficiency-driven processes.
Despite the bleak narrative of technocracy dominating humanity, the speaker suggests that reclaiming humane values through community and grace remains possible.
Deep dives
The Axiom of a Deteriorating Future
The idea that the future is always worse than expected is explored through various examples, illustrating a consistent pattern of societal decline. The speaker highlights instances from literature and media, such as P.D. James' novel 'Children of Men,' where dystopian predictions reflect current realities, like societal fixation on pets in the absence of children. This theme extends to the perceived conspiracy theories of government surveillance, which has manifested not through fear but through people's voluntary adoption of smartphones. Such narratives are tied to a broader notion that modern society has failed to progress in meaningful ways, reinforcing the axiom that our anticipated futures often fall short.
Technocracy versus the Craftsman
The speaker contrasts the humane approach of craftsmanship with the mechanistic nature of technocracy, emphasizing a loss of relational understanding in favor of efficiency. Craftsmanship involves a deep relationship between the creator and their work, where the artist infuses their being into their creation, such as a pot crafted from clay. This relationship fosters a world of interconnected arts and ends, promoting a social harmony. In contrast, technocracy strips away the human element, reducing individuals to mere components of a machine, leading to a disjointed society that prioritizes mechanized efficiency over meaningful interactions.
The Downward Spiral of Humanity
The speaker examines how a technocratic approach has historically eroded the humane aspects of civilization, particularly through warfare and societal conflict. He argues that as warfare became more mechanized and bureaucratic, the intrinsic values of honor and humanity were diminished, leading to the rise of total war. This shift is exemplified by the transformation of aristocratic warriors into interchangeable soldiers devoid of personal agency or ethical accountability. The dynamic of humanity being overshadowed by a faceless mechanism signifies a broader cultural decline where societies become increasingly dehumanized.
The Parasitic Nature of Technocracy
Technocracy is depicted as a parasitic force that thrives on the remnants of humane societies, exploiting their values while gradually dismantling the very foundations of humanity. The speaker highlights that while technocratic systems can initially exhibit growth through the resources of the humane world, they ultimately falter as those resources dwindle. The reliance on a diminished humane world fosters a cycle of exploitation, where the joyous aspects of living become overshadowed by a mechanistic, fearful existence. This predicament leads to a self-reinforcing system where domination over humanity becomes the norm, stifling individual creativity and depth.
Hope Through Counteroffensive
Despite the bleak outlook presented, hope emerges through the assertion that humanity can reclaim its dignity from technocratic systems. The speaker emphasizes that the remnants of humane societies provide a foundation for counterattacks against the encroaching technocracy, suggesting that there is always a potential for restoration. Christianity is presented as a powerful force that offers grace and a pathway to re-establishing humane bonds within society. This call to action inspires a vision where communities can transform their technological landscape, ensuring that the heart of humanity continues to beat, even amidst the challenges of modernity.
Are we headed to a grand and glorious technological future? In this talk, Andrew Willard Jones expects the opposite: "The Future is Always Worse Than You Think It Will Be." As he explains, there are two paths with the development on new technologies: one which leads to an extension of the humane world into greater areas, and another, the technocratic, which closes and mines the world from within.
This talk was given at the 2024 New Polity Conference "Should We, Therefore, Destroy the Servers?" Registration is open now for New Polity's 2025 conference "Our Kind of People." The early bird price ends on January 31st.