In this engaging conversation, Kelsey Burke, an associate professor of sociology and author of 'The Pornography Wars,' unpacks the intricate history of pornography in America. She explores the tug-of-war between feminist perspectives, the religious right, and sex worker rights, shedding light on their commonalities and conflicts. Burke also delves into societal perceptions of pornography addiction, challenging stigmas and presenting hidden narratives. Her insights on personal identity, morality, and the evolution of anti-porn movements make this a thought-provoking listen.
Dr. Kelsey Burke's personal journey from evangelical Christianity to exploring pornography underscores the complex interplay between faith and sexuality in American culture.
The podcast examines the divisive feminist perspectives on pornography, highlighting a spectrum of views on its impact on agency, empowerment, and exploitation.
Deep dives
Dr. Kelsey Burke's Personal Journey
Dr. Kelsey Burke's personal experience shapes her exploration of pornography, highlighting a unique intersection of faith and sexuality. Raised in a nominally religious environment, her teenage conversion to evangelical Christianity provided her a sense of belonging but came with rigid expectations about sexuality. Upon discovering her father's collection of Playboy magazines, she developed a fascination that juxtaposed her beliefs with her emerging identity. This duality ultimately led her to leave the church, illustrating how personal narratives inform her sociological research on pornography and its cultural implications.
Diverse Feminist Perspectives on Pornography
The podcast presents contrasting feminist perspectives on pornography, illustrating the complexity of the issue. Anti-porn feminists argue that pornography perpetuates violence against women, reducing them to mere sex objects and reinforcing patriarchal values. Conversely, some feminists and sex workers view certain types of pornography as empowering and emphasize that not all pornographic content is harmful. This discussion underscores the diversity of views within feminist discourse about sexuality, agency, and the marketplace of sexual representation.
Conservative Religious Views on Pornography
Conservative religious perspectives depict pornography as inherently harmful, intertwining it with issues of morality and societal decay. Many conservative Christians equate all forms of pornography with exploitation, aligning their anti-porn crusade with broader anti-sex trafficking efforts. The discourse often frames pornography consumption as detrimental to individual health, particularly among young men, indicating a growing concern about its impact on family and social values. This apprehension reflects a historical pattern where sexuality is constructed as a metric of national identity, driving ongoing moral debates in contemporary society.
The Interplay of Porn Addiction and Masculinity
The discussion includes how porn addiction is framed within conservative Christian circles, where notions of masculinity and control are central. Evangelical teachings suggest that strong sexual urges are natural for men, thus creating a conflict when these impulses are viewed as sinful. Interestingly, surveys indicate that white Protestant men perceive themselves as addicted to pornography more so than others, regardless of actual consumption patterns. This self-identification as 'addicted' often intersects violently in society, evidenced by tragic incidents where aggression is directed at women, revealing deep-seated societal contradictions regarding sexuality and morality.
Subscribe for $5.99 a month to get bonus content most Mondays, bonus episodes every month, ad-free listening, access to the entire 700-episode archive, Discord access, and more: https://axismundi.supercast.com/
Brad speaks with Dr. Kelsy Burke, a sociologist from the University of Nebraska, who discusses her new book The Pornography Wars: The Past, Present, and Future of America's Obscene Obsession.
Burke spent the last five years researching and interviewing internet pornography's opponents and its sympathizers. She does a deep dive into the long history of pornography in America and then turns her gaze on our present society to examine the ways this industry touches on the most intimate parts of American lives. She offers a complete understanding of the major players in the debates around porn's place in society: everyone from sex workers, activists, therapists, religious leaders, and consumers. In doing so, she addresses and debunks the myths that surround porn and porn usage while showing how everything from the way we teach children about sex to the legal protections for what can be published is tied up in the deeply complicated battles over pornography.