Media professor Steve Barnett and commentator David Elstein discuss the lack of balance in GB News, Ofcom's role in regulation, climate change denial vs. Holocaust denial, and the controversies surrounding GB News' owner and its impartiality. The podcast also explores the need for more regulation in broadcasting and the role of British individuals in American institutions.
GB News lacks balance in its roster of right-wing voices, raising concerns about its impartiality.
The media regulator Ofcom should enforce balance in politically opinionated broadcast news to ensure a fair and diverse media landscape.
Deep dives
Politically opinionated broadcast news in the UK
The podcast episode discusses politically opinionated broadcast news in the UK, focusing on the recent emergence of GB News. The episode explores the controversy surrounding the channel and its right-of-center lineup, including the addition of former Prime Minister Boris Johnson as a presenter. The role of the media regulator Ofcom is also examined, with criticisms raised about its handling of GB News and its failure to enforce due impartiality rules. The discussion delves into the legal and ethical implications of politically biased broadcast news, and raises questions about the need for regulation and the impact on democracy.
The challenges and consequences of politically biased news
The podcast episode highlights the challenges and consequences of politically biased news, focusing on GB News as an example. It discusses the potential impact of a channel like GB News, which leans towards the conservative perspective, and the concern that such channels can contribute to the polarization of public opinion. The legality of GB News in relation to due impartiality rules is brought into question, and the role of the media regulator Ofcom is examined. The episode considers the importance of a balanced and diverse media landscape in fostering informed and democratic societies.
The role of regulation and the media regulator Ofcom
The podcast episode delves into the role of regulation in the media landscape, particularly in relation to politically opinionated broadcast news. It analyzes the role of the media regulator Ofcom in monitoring and enforcing due impartiality rules. The episode raises concerns about the effectiveness of Ofcom and its handling of GB News, with criticisms raised about its failure to take serious action and its delayed response to investigations. The discussion highlights the need for a robust and proactive regulatory approach to ensure a fair and balanced media environment.
The implications for democracy and media trust
The podcast episode explores the implications of politically biased broadcast news on democracy and media trust. It examines the potential impact on public opinion and societal divisions, drawing parallels with the experiences of Fox News in the United States. The discussion emphasizes the importance of trusted and impartial news sources in navigating the information ecosystem, particularly in an era dominated by social media. The episode discusses the need for a balanced and regulated media landscape that upholds journalistic integrity and fosters public trust.
With former prime minister Boris Johnson soon joining Jacob Rees-Mogg, Lee Anderson and Nigel Farage as a presenter on GB News, there appears to be little attempt by the channel to provide balance to its roster of right-wing voices and even current Conservative politicians. Should the media regulator insist that it provides that balance, or should broadcasters be allowed to present just one side of a political argument?
On Media Confidential, Alan and Lionel hear from media professor Steve Barnett, a critic of Ofcom, and veteran commentator and TV executive David Elstein, who views the growth of GB News far more favourably.
Enjoy one-month's free trial to Prospect's digital content, and get full access to rigorously fact-checked, truly independent analysis and perspectives. No commitment - you can cancel at any time. Unlock your free digital trial today at https://subscription.prospectmagazine.co.uk/1mfd/prospect-magazine/mctex1mf