Apple Gets a Patent War for Christmas, Europe's Ability to Hijack the Regulatory Process, Systemic Questions After Adobe-Figma
Dec 20, 2023
auto_awesome
Apple's patent war, EU regulatory regime expansion, concerns over Adobe-Figma acquisition, and the impact of difficult tech mergers on the startup ecosystem are discussed in this episode.
The termination of the $20 billion merger between Adobe and Figma by EU regulators highlights concerns over anti-competitive behavior and potential harm to innovation in the design software market.
The power of EU regulators to influence deals involving US companies raises broader structural questions regarding international regulation and the impact on future acquisitions and mergers in the technology sector.
The blockage of mergers and acquisitions poses challenges for startups and tech investors, limiting their options for exit strategies and potentially stifling innovation and growth in the ecosystem.
Deep dives
EU regulators terminate Adobe-Figma merger
Regulators in the UK and EU forced the termination of a $20 billion merger between Adobe and Figma, citing concerns over anti-competitive behavior and potential harm to innovation. Figma, a fast-growing product design platform, was valued at $10 billion and seen as a rival to Adobe's XD application. The EU regulators' worry was that Adobe's dominance in the design software market could stifle Figma's independent growth and innovation. The termination of the deal requires Adobe to pay Figma a $1 billion reverse termination fee in cash.
EU regulators and anti-competitive concerns
The EU regulators argued that Adobe's near monopoly in the design software market, combined with the acquisition of a growing competitor like Figma, could harm competition and innovation. Critics of the merger expressed similar concerns, suggesting that independent growth for Figma could drive more innovation in the industry. However, Adobe pushed back on these claims throughout the investigation.
Structural questions and EU intervention
The case highlights broader structural questions regarding international regulation and the power of EU regulators to influence deals involving US companies. The slow nature of the regulatory process and potential anti-competitive concerns raised by the EU could impact future acquisitions and mergers in the technology sector.
The expertise of Figma and Adobe in the design space
While Figma is often seen as a competitor to Adobe's XD, Adobe's software offerings, such as Photoshop and Illustrator, provide a deeper level of design capabilities. Figma's strength lies in collaboration and interaction design, focusing on teamwork and streamlining the design process for complex projects. The termination of the merger raises questions about the balance between competition and innovation in the design software market.
Figma's Disruptive Influence on Adobe
Figma, a design application, poses a fundamental threat to Adobe's business model and dominance in the market. Figma's collaborative features and high-performance rendering engine have allowed it to gain widespread adoption and become the go-to platform for designing web pages and applications. Its collaborative approach, in contrast to Adobe's single-player mindset, has given Figma a competitive edge. This acquisition would have eliminated a significant threat for Adobe, solidifying Figma as the central hub for design work and potentially diminishing the need for Adobe's flagship products like Photoshop. The failure to block this merger highlights the lack of understanding and the potential negative implications for the innovation ecosystem.
Implications for Startups and Tech Investors
The blockage of mergers and acquisitions poses challenges for startups and tech investors. Without the option to sell to larger companies like Adobe, startups face increased competition and difficulties in realizing returns on their investments. The big companies, still wielding significant market power, can make it even harder for startups by attempting to stifle innovation or compete aggressively. The absence of acquisition as an exit strategy raises concerns about the future of the ecosystem, as it limits the efficiency and attractiveness of investment. The tension between promoting competition and impeding acquisitions presents a complex issue that requires a nuanced approach for sustained innovation and growth.
The patent dispute that has Apple ready to take Apple Watches off the market, the expanding powers of the EU regulatory regime, why the Adobe-Figma acquisition raised legitimate competition concerns, and the uncertainty for the startup ecosystem as mergers become more difficult across tech.
Adobe abandons $20 billion acquisition of Figma — The Verge
Adobe to Buy Collaboration-Software Company Figma for About $20 Billion — Wall Street Journal
Adobe Acquires Figma, Figma’s Disruption, The Figma OS — Stratechery Update
Get Sharp Tech Premium, Sharp China, Stratechery Update, Stratechery Interviews, Greatest of All Talk and the Dithering Podcast as part of Stratechery Plus for $12/month.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
