#11992 Why Don’t You Think Catholicism Makes Sense? - Karlo Broussard
Dec 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Karlo Broussard, a guest speaker for Catholic Answers Live, dives into some intriguing questions about Catholicism. He tackles the confusion around differing parish practices and the reasons behind the Church's historical splits. Broussard explains the biblical roots of the Immaculate Conception, defends the importance of repetitive prayer, and engages thoughtfully with a caller's skepticism from an atheist perspective. His discussions encourage listeners to find deeper meaning and understanding in their faith journey.
The lack of uniformity in the Catholic Church reflects human flaws, emphasizing adherence to divine revelation over individual practices or behaviors.
The theological differences between Catholicism and Orthodoxy, especially regarding the Pope's authority, reveal the complex historical context of their schism.
Deep dives
Engaging with Doubts about Catholic Uniformity
A caller expressed concerns about perceived inconsistencies within the Catholic Church, particularly regarding the lack of uniformity in teaching and moral standards among priests. This unease stems from observing some priests who appear to embrace behaviors contrary to traditional Catholic doctrine, such as openly accepting same-sex relationships or failing to address issues like excessive drinking within their congregations. The response highlighted that Christ never promised complete uniformity among individuals on the ground, allowing for human flaws and failings among church leaders. Instead, the uniformity Christ promised pertains more to adherence to divine revelation and the teachings of the magisterium, fostering peace in the knowledge that God allows for human imperfections while maintaining truth in relation to faith and morals.
Understanding the Catholic and Orthodox Distinction
A discussion arose regarding the differences between Catholicism and Orthodox Christianity, tracing back to the historical and theological contexts of their schism. The key point of contention is the role and authority of the Pope, with Catholics believing in the Pope's supreme authority over all bishops and the church, while Orthodox Christians view his role more as a primacy of honor without supreme governance. This distinction reflects deeper theological nuances, including beliefs about apostolic succession and the nature of the church's authority. These contrasts are pivotal to understanding the historical split and ongoing dialogue between the two faiths, prompting inquiries into the rich and complex history leading to these differences.
The Nature of Repetitious Prayer
A caller expressed struggles with the concept of repetitious prayer, particularly regarding the Rosary, noting that believers from other traditions often criticize such practices. The response emphasized that repetitious prayers are not only biblically endorsed but also serve as a way to deepen one's faith and connection with God. Scriptural examples, including Jesus’ own repetitive prayers in the Garden of Gethsemane, highlight that repetition can be a heartfelt expression of devotion. Repetitious prayer, like the Hail Mary in the Rosary, can help focus the mind on sacred mysteries and facilitate an ongoing relationship with God, emphasizing that such practices stem from love, remembrance, and an aspiration for holiness.
Exploring Atheism and the Quest for God
In a thought-provoking conversation, an atheist caller inquired about the rationale for believing in Catholicism, prompting a response centered on the existence of God as a necessary starting point. The dialogue encouraged the exploration of philosophical arguments that might posit an uncaused cause, linking those to the existence of a personal, conscious deity as understood in Christian belief. Suggested resources included works by philosophers and theologians that provide arguments for God's existence and support faith in Jesus Christ as the incarnate Word. This exchange highlighted the importance of open dialogue in addressing doubts and exploring the profound truths and reasons for faith within Catholicism, particularly relevant during the Christmas season.
Questions covered:
02:53 – Why is there no uniformity in the Church. Some of the differing practices of parishes seem to contradict each other?
14:20 – I don’t understand why the Church split up.
20:52 – I don’t understand the biblical basis for the Immaculate Conception.
30:12 – Why do Catholics use repetitive prayer? I don’t understand why you should say more than one at a time.
41:58 – Why should I believe in Catholicism? I am an atheist.
…
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode