William Arkin, a bestselling author, military expert, and former intelligence analyst, delves into the evolution of warfare from the World Wars to modern conflicts. He discusses how the battlefield has transformed with technology and volunteer armies, leading to a disconnect between civilians and the military. Arkin highlights the shift from total war tactics to high-tech innovations like precision bombing, and questions the effectiveness of ongoing military operations. His insights reveal the complexities of contemporary warfare and changing public perceptions.
Warfare has transformed from total mobilization in the World Wars to advanced technology reliance, exemplified by drone and air power dominance.
Modern conflicts reveal that high-tech military strategies can lead to prolonged instability, emphasizing the need for deeper local understanding.
Deep dives
Transformation of Warfare Since World Wars
Warfare has evolved significantly since the periods of the World Wars, shifting from total mobilization for conflict to a model characterized by smaller, volunteer armies and advanced technology. The introduction of guerrilla tactics during the Vietnam War marked a pivotal change, allowing for engagements without a clear front line. Current military strategies often leverage high-tech assets such as drones and intelligence systems, rendering geography less relevant in strategic operations. This transformation has changed how conflicts are waged, with air power playing a critical role in successful military campaigns, such as the 2003 invasion of Iraq.
The Role of Air Power in Modern Conflicts
Air power has become the dominant force in contemporary warfare, enabling military forces to conduct operations that range far in advance of ground troops. Examples from the 2003 Gulf War illustrate how air strikes effectively dismantled enemy defenses before land forces engaged, illustrating the shift from traditional battleground engagements. Modern techniques, such as the JDAM bomb, enhance strike accuracy regardless of weather conditions, allowing for precise targeting that reduces reliance on traditional ground troops. This evolution highlights a dependency on advanced technology that continues to reshape military strategies and battle dynamics.
Challenges in Modern Military Engagements
Despite technological advancements, modern conflicts often reveal the limitations of military strategies rooted in air power and over-reliance on advanced systems. Campaigns in Iraq and Afghanistan demonstrated that rapid, high-tech victories could lead to prolonged instability, highlighting the dangers of insufficient ground presence. The insurgencies that emerged post-conflict stemmed from an incomplete understanding of the local dynamics and failure to eliminate the enemy's fighting capability. This raises concerns about whether the current military approach truly fosters long-term peace or merely results in perpetual engagements.
Public Disengagement and Future of Warfare
The disconnect between American society and its military engagements is accentuated by the transformation of warfare into a high-tech enterprise with limited public involvement. Current military forces depend on professionals who are increasingly removed from the general population, resulting in challenges for recruitment and public interest. The U.S. military's shift toward technology has created an environment where fewer troops are required on the ground, yet conflicts continue without meaningful resolution. This pattern suggests a future of warfare that may be defined by technological dominance rather than substantive victories, leading to ongoing military actions detached from public consciousness.
The World Wars were total. Entire populations were mobilised at home and away. Part of our fascination with them lies in the fact that our modern wars look entirely different. They are fought by volunteer armies with smart, modern technology. William Arkin is a bestselling author, military expert, and award-winning journalist. He is also a former intelligence analyst. William came onto the podcast to talk to James about how the battlefield has developed since the end of the Second World War. He traces the fall of the ‘front line’ and the development of new weapons which have brought an end to the need for feet on the ground. This is a great insight into the workings of war and the changes in public attitudes towards it.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode