When it comes to harassment, are federal judges above the law?
Mar 3, 2025
auto_awesome
Carrie Johnson, NPR's justice correspondent, shines a light on the troubling realities within the federal court system. An extensive investigation reveals a toxic culture of harassment and intimidation, especially faced by law clerks. Victims share heart-wrenching stories of assault, struggling with the lack of protections and the fear of retaliation. The discussion uncovers the systemic issues that silence victims and explores legislative efforts aimed at enhancing accountability. Johnson’s insights underscore a need for change in how harassment is addressed in the judiciary.
The podcast reveals a troubling culture within the federal judiciary that discourages reporting sexual harassment due to fear of retaliation.
Legislative efforts, like the Judiciary Accountability Act, aim to extend vital workplace protections to federal court employees, highlighting the need for reform.
Deep dives
The Experience of a Law Clerk
A law clerk in Alaska entered a prestigious position hoping to advance her legal career, only to face severe workplace harassment from the federal judge she worked for. The uncomfortable encounters began with inappropriate conversations about the judge's personal life, which escalated into constant texting that felt like an unending pressure. The situation reached a critical point when the judge revealed he had exchanged nude photos with a prosecutor, prompting the clerk to seek a way out of her uncomfortable environment. Despite moving on to a new job as a federal prosecutor, she found that the toxic dynamics of the federal court system persisted.
Challenges in Reporting Misconduct
The podcast highlights significant gaps in the federal judiciary's handling of sexual harassment and bullying, particularly the overwhelming fear among clerks to report abusive behavior. A former law clerk’s experience demonstrates that even when misconduct is reported, systemic issues make it difficult for victims to find justice or adequate support. In one case, a mentor who was aware of the judge's inappropriate actions betrayed the clerk's confidence, revealing the intense pressure and vulnerability clerks face. This culture of silence and retaliation discourages many from speaking out, further perpetuating a toxic work environment.
Calls for Legal Reform
The episode also explores the push for legislative reform aimed at providing better protections for those working within the federal court system. Lawmakers, such as Congresswoman Norma Torres and Congressman Hank Johnson, are advocating for the Judiciary Accountability Act, which seeks to extend the same legal protections that exist for private sector employees to those in the federal judiciary. The lack of effective oversight and recourse for clerks who experience harassment demonstrates the need for fundamental changes in how the judicial system holds judges accountable. As calls for reform continue, there remains a pervasive sentiment that the judiciary is often more protective of its own than of the employees who serve within it.
People who work for the federal court system don't have the same kinds of job protections that most other Americans do.
A nearly year-long NPR investigation has found problems with the way the courts police sexual harassment and bullying...and a pervasive culture of fear about blowing the whistle.
A warning to our listeners, this piece contains a description of sexual assault.
For sponsor-free episodes of Consider This, sign up for Consider This+ via Apple Podcasts or at plus.npr.org.