Helen Lewis, a staff writer at The Atlantic and author, dives into the intricacies of modern journalism and the challenges of reporting amidst political polarization. She discusses the impact of social media on truth and the role of journalism in a hyper-partisan climate. The conversation also covers controversial topics like DEI initiatives, feminism, and trans rights, advocating for nuanced dialogue. Lewis critically examines the Rotherham scandal and the systemic issues it reveals, emphasizing the need for accountability and deeper understanding in today’s complex media landscape.
Helen Lewis stresses that journalism must prioritize accurate facts and diverse perspectives to navigate complex narratives effectively.
The podcast highlights how Lewis believes that a more opinionated journalism can help combat the overshadowing of authentic reporting by influencers.
Differences in media biases between US and UK journalism are explored, emphasizing the need for fair representation and dissenting voices.
Lewis warns that extreme political polarization hinders civil discourse, urging for cooperation and understanding among conflicting viewpoints to improve democracy.
Deep dives
Helen Lewis's Journalistic Philosophy
Helen Lewis emphasizes that journalism should prioritize gathering factual information and representing diverse perspectives accurately. She compares the complexities of storytelling to the Rashomon effect, where different people perceive the same event differently. This illustrates the intricate challenge journalists face in discerning the truth amidst conflicting narratives. Ultimately, Lewis believes that good journalism requires hard intellectual work to navigate these varying interpretations while maintaining a commitment to factual reporting.
The Influence of Commentary in Journalism
Lewis candidly acknowledges her own inclination towards commentary in her writing, admitting that she struggles to maintain a purely objective reporting style. She argues that while there are journalists dedicated solely to reporting the facts, this approach can sometimes lead to a lack of engagement with the underlying issues. Instead, she believes that journalism can benefit from a more opinionated voice that calls out societal absurdities, akin to the boy in 'The Emperor's New Clothes'. This approach, she suggests, can help combat the trend of influencers overshadowing authentic journalism.
Cultural and Political Differences in Journalism
The conversation explores differences between US and UK journalism, noting that both regions deal with unique challenges of media bias and public trust. Lewis reflects on how the British media, particularly the BBC, attempts to ensure impartiality, while American media often lacks balance, with networks heavily favoring one political viewpoint. She highlights the importance of maintaining a space for dissenting voices, suggesting that the media landscape could benefit from revisiting the principles of fair representation. This contrast reveals how differing political cultures shape journalism's role in each country.
The Dangers of Hyper-Partisanship
Lewis discusses the extreme polarization evident in US politics, warning that voters on both sides often demonize the opposing party, leading to a toxic political environment. She expresses concern that hyper-partisanship restricts dialogue and understanding between political factions, reflecting on the implications this has for democracy. Highlighting that youth are influenced by filtered narratives, she emphasizes the need for civil discourse to foster cooperation and understanding among differing viewpoints. The lack of swing voters in the political landscape adds to the challenge of mitigating this division.
Social Media's Impact on Public Discourse
Lewis critiques how the internet allows individuals to isolate themselves within echo chambers, exacerbating societal divisions. She highlights the emergence of unhealthy communities that thrive on negative reinforcement, particularly in relation to issues like eating disorders. The hyper-personalization of social media leads to both the formation of niche groups and an inability to engage with differing perspectives effectively. This phenomenon raises questions about the long-term effects of online communities on individuals' worldviews.
The Rotherham Scandal and Issues of Accountability
The Rotherham child exploitation scandal is discussed as a poignant example of systemic failure in addressing deeply embedded issues of misogyny and race. Lewis acknowledges the real scandal of failing to protect vulnerable young girls while recognizing the complexities of linking crime to cultural factors. She expresses frustration at the politicization of the issue, where genuine discussions about accountability are overshadowed by extremist narratives. This conversation emphasizes the need for thoughtful approaches to complex societal problems, rather than reductive ideologies.
Navigating the Tensions of Free Speech
Lewis reflects on the challenges of upholding free speech while combating misinformation and the dangers posed by ill-intentioned actors. She argues that while individuals should be free to express opinions, those opinions must come with accountability and consequences for harmful misinformation. The conversation underscores the difficulty of ensuring civil discourse amidst a landscape where misinformation spreads without repercussions. The need for responsible dialogue and meaningful discourse, where individuals are held accountable for their statements, is paramount to navigating this landscape productively.
Sam Harris speaks with Helen Lewis about the culture wars. They discuss the role of journalists, DEI, political polarization, feminism, transgender activism, gender roles, the Rotherham scandal, Islam and jihadism, Elon Musk and X, the future of the Democratic Party, and other topics.
Helen Lewis is a staff writer at The Atlantic, where she writes about politics and culture. Last year, she traveled to Austin to explore what Joe Rogan has done to the city, profiled the controversial American literacy guru Lucy Calkins, and spent the election campaign season in Pennsylvania.
Helen is also the host of the BBC's Strong Message Here and Helen Lewis Has Left The Chat. Her first book, Difficult Women: A History of Feminism in 11 Fights, was a Sunday Times bestseller. Her second book, The Genius Myth, explores how the modern idea of genius―a class of special people―is distorting our view of the world. It will be published in the summer by Jonathan Cape (UK) and Thesis (US). She writes a weekly Substack, The Bluestocking.
Learning how to train your mind is the single greatest investment you can make in life. That’s why Sam Harris created the Waking Up app. From rational mindfulness practice to lessons on some of life’s most important topics, join Sam as he demystifies the practice of meditation and explores the theory behind it.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
