
The Tikvah Podcast Yonah Jeremy Bob and Elliot Kaufman on Israel's Wartime Decisions
Oct 22, 2026
Yonah Jeremy Bob, a Jerusalem Post military correspondent and intelligence analyst, and Elliot Kaufman, a Wall Street Journal opinion writer covering Israel and foreign affairs, examine Israel’s wartime decision-making. They explore rivalries among Netanyahu, Gallant, and Gantz; whether to confront Hamas or Hezbollah first; the hostages’ impact on Gaza strategy; and the high-stakes pager operation and Nasrallah’s assassination.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Officials Wrote Their Legacies During The War
- Israeli and American officials shaped their historical reputations while making wartime decisions.
- The reporters tested competing narratives through repeated interviews, documents, diaries, and “ping pong” between opposing accounts.
Gallant Became The War Room’s Road Not Taken
- Benny Gantz treated politics as national duty, while Yoav Gallant repeatedly represented alternatives the war room rejected.
- Gallant first favored striking Hezbollah, then urged a Gaza hostage deal to prevent dangerous escalation.
Netanyahu Shifted From Caution To Boldness
- Netanyahu initially delayed invading Gaza because he doubted Israeli military readiness after October 7.
- His later confidence grew from successful Gaza operations, enabling bolder campaigns against Hezbollah and Iran.







