Starmer suspends seven MPs, what precedent does this set?
Jul 25, 2024
auto_awesome
Keir Starmer suspends seven Labour MPs for defying party whip on benefits cap. Guests discuss Labour's divisions, fiscal policy challenges, and Tory leadership race. Also, analysis on economic reforms, populism, and Virginia Woolf's legacy.
Starmer's swift action against dissent showcases Labour's internal discipline and commitment to party manifesto promises.
The emergence of multiple candidates for Conservative leadership indicates a competitive and dynamic race ahead.
Deep dives
Leadership Discipline in the Labour Party
The Labour Party, under Kier Starmer's leadership, has demonstrated a swift and uncompromising stance towards dissent within its ranks, particularly evident in the recent withdrawal of the whip from seven MPs who opposed a key party amendment. This move, unprecedented for a government holding a significant majority, serves to reinforce internal discipline and signal commitment to manifesto promises even in the face of opposition challenges.
Conservative Leadership Race
The emergence of multiple candidates vying for the Conservative leadership, including James Cleverley, Tom Tugendhat, and Robert Jenrick, marks the beginning of a dynamic and potentially competitive race within the party. While Cleverley emphasizes unity and broad appeal, Tugendhat's shift towards the right mirrors a trend in recent party history. The entry of significant female contenders like Suella Braverman and Priti Patel further adds intrigue to the unfolding leadership contest.
GB Energy and Renewed Public Ownership
The introduction of GB Energy and the collaboration with the Crown Estate signify a return of public ownership into mainstream policy discussions, aligning with Labour's emphasis on green investment and broader societal benefits. By involving private sector partnerships, this initiative seeks to accelerate renewable energy projects while navigating fiscal constraints, underscoring a strategic and politically astute approach to infrastructure development.
Joe Biden's Economic Reforms and Legacy
In assessing Joe Biden's economic policy shifts and the critique of his populist stance, contrasting viewpoints highlight the complexities of his administration's approach. While some argue for his initiative in challenging neoliberal norms through deficit spending, others caution against labeling him populist due to the financing mechanisms employed. These discussions reflect ongoing debates on the economic legacy and leadership style of the Biden administration.
Keir Starmer’s leadership of the Labour party has been described countless times over the past 4 years as ‘ruthless’, and this week we saw this in action for the first time as prime minister withdrawing the Labour whip from seven MPs who voted with an SNP amendment to scrap the two child cap in certain benefits.
Hannah Barnes, associate editor, is joined by senior editor George Eaton, and political correspondent Freddie Hayward.
Sign up to the New Statesman's daily politics newsletter: Morning Call
Submit a question for a future episode: You Ask Us