Stephanie Coontz, an expert on family structures, discusses the history of friendship and marriage. They explore the changes in societal perceptions over time and the importance of friendship in older societies. The conversation touches on decluttering homes, the significance of taking breaks, and the relationship between friendship and marriage.
Throughout history, friendship has served as a deep human bond, evolving from cooperation and reciprocity in foraging societies.
Culture, media, and social norms heavily influence perceptions of friendship and marriage, often favoring marriage as a more institutionalized institution compared to friendship.
Deep dives
The Evolution of Friendship and Marriage
Throughout history, the concept of friendship has been closely tied to cooperation and reciprocity, dating back even to foraging societies. Kinship was not necessarily the basis of human cooperation but rather the outcome of it. Marriage, in those early societies, served as a way to turn strangers into kin and to establish connections with other individuals and their families. As societies evolved and surpluses were produced, wealth disparities emerged, and friendship started to become more instrumental, serving to obtain resources or emotional support. In the 17th and 18th centuries, friendships became crucial, especially between men and between women, as marriage was not yet highly sexualized and emotional connections with peers were highly valued. However, with the rise of sexualized marriage ideals in the early 20th century, friendships between men and women became suspect, and male-male and female-female friendships were discouraged. The 1950s reinforced the idea that family should take priority over friendships, leading to a decline in the importance of friendships. In recent years, there has been a resurgence in exploring the balance between passionate romantic relationships and intense friendships.
Transmission of Cultural Ideas on Friendship and Marriage
The transmission of ideas and norms surrounding friendship and marriage is influenced by societal influencers and elites who reinforce existing power structures. Experts and media play a role in shaping societal attitudes towards relationships. In the early 20th century, with the advent of television, messages about the primacy of marriage and the devaluation of friendships were broadcasted widely. These messages were received by individuals grappling with dilemmas and contradictions in their lives, seeking answers and guidance. Culture, media, and social norms play a significant role in shaping perceptions of friendship and marriage, often favoring marriage as a more institutionalized institution compared to friendship.
The Fluidity of Relationships and Challenges in Modern Times
Friendship and marriage face different challenges in modern times. Marriage often comes with high barriers to exit, making it harder to leave unsatisfactory relationships. Friendship, on the other hand, typically lacks the same barriers, allowing for greater flexibility. However, this also raises questions about how to cultivate meaningful and supportive friendships that can withstand difficult times, without sacrificing personal growth and the ability to leave toxic relationships. Striking a balance between commitment and the freedom to prioritize personal well-being is a perpetual challenge in navigating romantic and friendship relationships.
The Importance of Friendship and Future Directions
Research shows that strong friendship networks contribute to well-being and happiness, particularly in old age. Friendship provides significant support, and individuals with larger networks of friends report better overall health. As society continues to navigate the complexities of modern relationships, it is essential to recognize the value of friendship alongside romantic relationships. This involves understanding the unique role friendships play in our lives and finding ways to strengthen and support these connections alongside marriage and family commitments.
Marriage didn't always wreck friendships among women, as it did the 1950s, or strain both beloved relationships, as often happens today. Stephanie Coontz studies the long history of family structures from forager society to the present. History has some stark (and cheering) lessons about the ways that friendship functions as a deep human bond. Plus, we're renewed, refreshed, and restored after taking a break and doing a full home reorganization.