Who cared? The disappearance of Amber Haigh: the verdict
Sep 17, 2024
auto_awesome
Ben Doherty, a seasoned journalist, and Bridie Jabour, an insightful reporter, delve into the complex case of Amber Haigh's disappearance. They dissect the recent not guilty verdict for Robert and Anne Jeeves, exploring the prosecution's failures and the emotional impact on Amber's family. The conversation reveals flaws in the police investigation and the influence of past allegations on the trial. With the courtroom drama laid bare, they question the intricacies of justice and the lingering doubts surrounding this heart-wrenching case.
The not guilty verdict for Robert and Anne Jeeves highlights the critical importance of substantial evidence and the high burden of proof in criminal cases.
Justice Lonergan's examination of Amber Haigh's troubled upbringing underscores the broader societal issues regarding vulnerable individuals and their relationships with potentially harmful influences.
Deep dives
The Court Verdict
The verdict of not guilty in the trial of Robert and Ann Jeeves for the murder of Amber Haig has left many in shock, as Justice Julia Lonergan acknowledged that while Amber is deceased, the evidence presented did not meet the standard of proof required for a conviction. The trial, which shifted from Wagga Wagga to Sydney, culminated with a tense courtroom atmosphere filled with family, media, and members of the public awaiting the decision. Justice Lonergan emphasized the necessity of substantial evidence and the high burden of proof required for a guilty verdict, ultimately leading to the acquittal of the Jeeves couple. This outcome reignites questions and suspicions about Amber Haig's fate and underscores the lingering pain felt by her loved ones, who are no closer to finding closure.
Amber Haig's Difficult Life
Justice Lonergan gave significant attention to Amber Haig's troubled upbringing, detailing her unstable family life marked by an abusive father and a lack of support. Amber faced numerous challenges, including health issues and an intellectual disability, leading her to be vulnerable and often seeking acceptance in unsafe environments. Her relationship with the Jeeves family, where she found temporary refuge, was scrutinized, with evidence indicating that she became involved with Robert Jeeves, who was much older and provided her with some support. The judge noted that throughout her life, Amber struggled to find love and stability, culminating in her tragic disappearance.
Flaws in the Investigation
The investigation into Amber Haig's disappearance has faced criticism, particularly regarding its initial phases where police focused more on disproving the Jeeves’ accounts rather than objectively investigating her case. Justice Lonergan highlighted the shortcomings of the police investigation, accusing it of being fixated on the Jeeves as suspects without thoroughly exploring other leads or evidence. The judge also pointed out that recordings made during the investigation failed to yield any incriminating evidence against the Jeeves, further complicating the case. Additionally, a new witness's testimony emerged more than 19 years later, but the judge dismissed it as unreliable, reflecting the challenges that continue to surround the search for truth in Amber's case.
Amber Haigh was 19 years old when she disappeared in 2002, leaving behind an infant son. For months Robert and Anne Geeves sat in court accused of her murder but this week the verdict came down from the judge: not guilty. They are now free. Ben Doherty tells Bridie Jabour about the two ‘indispensable facts’ the judge says the prosecution failed to prove
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
.jpg&w=320&h=320&output=jpg)
