The Big Story An inside look at what it's like to be a sequestered juror in a criminal case in Canada
Jul 7, 2025
Nick Westoll, a CityNews reporter from Toronto, shares his firsthand experience serving as a juror in a criminal case. He discusses the stark contrast between Hollywood portrayals and the reality of jury duty, including the rigorous selection process and emotional toll of decision-making. Nick reveals the complexities of being sequestered, the pressures of achieving a unanimous verdict, and the mental health challenges faced by jurors. He also highlights the financial struggles due to low compensation in Ontario, advocating for reform.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Jury Selection Experience
- Nick Westoll received a survey for jury duty and soon was summoned despite his journalist profession.
- He described the official courthouse process, including screening and selection by a wooden drum raffle-like method.
Jury Selection Differences
- Jury selection differs between civil and criminal cases, with lawyers having more exclusion powers in civil trials.
- Criminal juries require 12 jurors, and many people get excluded for various legal or personal reasons.
Jurors Judge Facts Only
- Jurors are to judge only the facts and disregard legal interpretation; the judge rules on law.
- Jurors must avoid external research to stay impartial despite natural instincts.