King Charles, Lidia Thorpe and the pursuit of justice
Oct 24, 2024
auto_awesome
Paul Bongiorno, a political columnist for The Saturday Paper, dives into the heated discourse following King Charles' first visit to Australia. He discusses Lidia Thorpe's striking protest, emphasizing ongoing struggles for Indigenous rights. The conversation shifts to the enduring Australian republican movement and the implications of recent referendums. Bongiorno also addresses global issues like climate change and reparations discussed at the Commonwealth meeting, questioning the path forward for justice and recognition in Australian society.
Senator Lidia Thorpe's protest against King Charles highlighted ongoing frustrations regarding Indigenous rights and the demand for recognition of historical injustices.
The podcast discusses the broader implications of Thorpe's actions for the Australian republican movement and the stalled conversations on treaties and reparations.
Deep dives
Indigenous Protest and Monarchy's Legacy
Senator Lydia Thorpe's protest during King Charles' visit to Australia underscored ongoing frustrations regarding Indigenous rights and colonial injustices. She vocally challenged the legitimacy of the monarchy, claiming sovereignty for her people and demanding acknowledgment of historical wrongs, including genocide and land dispossession. This act of defiance did not go unnoticed; while it sparked international dialogues, it also drew condemnation from some political figures and Indigenous leaders who felt it was inappropriate. Thorpe's actions highlighted the pressing need for discussions about treaties and reparations in the face of a constitutional monarchy perceived as outdated and unaccountable.
Media Response and Political Backlash
Thorpe’s audacious comments gained significant media coverage, both domestically and internationally, as she articulated the grievances of First Australians against the monarchy. Despite receiving support from some political allies for her bold stance, she also faced backlash, with critics questioning her loyalty to the parliamentary system she represents. Figures such as the opposition leader called for her resignation, arguing that if she rejects the institution, she should not continue to benefit from it. The diverse reactions to Thorpe's protest reveal a deep division within Australian society regarding the monarchy, Indigenous rights, and the legacy of colonialism.
Challenges to Australia’s Republican Movement
The royal visit reignited discussions about Australia's position on having a republic, especially following the recent failure of the voice referendum. Political sentiments toward republicanism appear subdued at this time, with the current Prime Minister stating there would only be one referendum during his term. Discussions about the monarchy's role and potential for reforms have been parked, with an uncertain future on the horizon for those advocating for change. As frustration remains high over Indigenous recognition and justice, proponents of a republic fear that the momentum for their cause could fade further.
King Charles’ first visit to Australia as monarch laid bare a lot of unfinished business.
Moments after the king sat down following an address to the Great Hall in Parliament House, independent Senator Lidia Thorpe was escorted out after shouting “you are not our king” and “this is not your land”.
It didn’t just bring home the fact that, despite a failed referendum in 1999, the Australian republican movement is still alive – it also highlighted that the more recent failed referendum on a Voice to Parliament has far from settled any of the issues around Truth, Treaty and justice.
Today, columnist for The Saturday Paper Paul Bongiorno, on the demands from Australia and other colonies for justice and reparations.