Meet Neil Harris Jr., a mysterious man found in Riverside Park whose true identity and backstory were discovered after his death. Explore the captivating history of Hart Island, a haunting burial ground in the Bronx, and the forgotten stories of those laid to rest there. Uncover Neil's encounter with a journalist who recognizes him as a missing person, and the subsequent revelation of his identity. Susan Holbert shares her son's story and the opening of Hart Island after years of inaccessibility. Discover the intriguing mysteries unearthed from America's largest public cemetery.
The episode highlights the tragic story of Neil Harris Jr., a man who lived two different lives under different names and was buried in an unmarked grave on Hart Island.
Stephen, also known as Neil, had a profound impact on the community of Riverside Park, where his presence and gentle demeanor touched the lives of many, showcasing the power of anonymous figures in our lives.
Deep dives
Unidentified man buried in plot 383
The podcast episode explores the story of an unidentified man who was buried in plot 383 on Hart Island, off the coast of the Bronx in New York City. Despite several efforts to find his identity, he remained nameless. The man had lived two different lives under different names. His mother, Susan Herrobert, reveals that his birth name was Neil and shares memories of his early life. Neil's mother recalls his changing behavior and mental health struggles, which eventually led to his diagnosis of schizophrenia. Over time, he drifted away from his family and became estranged. Eventually, he ended up living in Riverside Park as Stephen, a gentle yet mysterious presence. After Neil's tragic death, the community where he frequented for years organized a memorial service to honor his memory.
Neighbors' bond with Stephen/Neil
Stephen, also known as Neil, became an integral part of the neighborhood in Riverside Park, forming connections with various individuals. Billy, a park regular, describes Stephen as reserved and not a talker, yet his presence was a constant. Others, like Jim and Jessica, recognized Stephen's familiar face in the park and shared acts of kindness towards him, like bringing him magazines and offering food. Stephen's impact extended beyond his unidentified status, as children and local residents felt a connection to him. His presence on the bench, his gentle demeanor, and the loss the community felt after his passing illustrate the power of anonymous figures in our lives.
The search for Neil's identity
Jessica, a journalist who often saw Stephen in Riverside Park, takes it upon herself to investigate his true identity. Through her research, she finds a missing persons database where she recognizes a photo of Stephen as Neil Harris Jr. Intrigued, she contacts Neil's mother, Susan Herrobert, who has been tirelessly searching for her son. The revelation brings a mix of emotions for Susan, who is initially skeptical about the connection, but ultimately finds closure and affirmation after seeing the photo of her son from the medical examiner's office. Neil's tragic fate becomes known to his mother, but the search for his identity and the resounding impact he had on the community shed light on the interconnectedness of people's lives.
A few years ago, a young man who called himself Stephen became a fixture in Manhattan’s Riverside Park. Locals started noticing him sitting on the same park bench day after day. He said little and asked for nothing.
When Stephen’s body was found in 2017, the police were unable to identify him, and he was buried on Hart Island. Then, one day, a woman who knew him from the park stumbled upon his true identity, and his backstory came to light.
This is the first episode in our new series The Unmarked Graveyard, untangling mysteries from America’s largest public cemetery. Each week, we’re bringing you stories of how people ended up on Hart Island, the lives they lived and the people they left behind.