When two people disagree, their ideas are not automatically equally plausible. Some ideas are superior than others.
Proposition X is not equally reasonable as proposition Y simply because they are both propositions. I call this an "abstraction error", and you see it everywhere in the world of ideas.
Cultures, ideas, political theories, epistemologies - we cannot evaluate them in the abstract. We have to dive into the concrete.
Get full access to Steve Patterson's Substack at stevepatterson.substack.com/subscribe