
The Herd with Colin Cowherd Colin Cowherd Podcast - Cowboys STUN Eagles, Chiefs Stay Alive, Bears Stay Hot, JJ McCarthy Is NOT An NFL Quarterback, Sheuder Earned Another Start
Nov 24, 2025
Colin is joined by John Middlekauff, a former NFL scout and host of '3 and Out', who brings keen insights into the latest NFL action. They discuss the Cowboys' dramatic comeback against the Eagles and highlight Philadelphia's offensive struggles. John shares thoughts on Shedeur Sanders' promising debut, while Colin critiques Daniel Jones for the Colts' loss to the Chiefs. They also declare J.J. McCarthy unfit for the NFL and laud JSN's standout performance for the Seahawks, rounding off the analysis with a look at coaching decisions impacting teams like USC.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Eagles' Run Failure Fueled Collapse
- The Eagles' collapse wasn't just Jalen Hurts; their inability to run the ball doomed them in the second half.
- Colin Cowherd and John Middlekauff emphasize that elite teams can't have repeated anemic offensive halves against rivals.
George Pickens Is Earning A New Deal
- George Pickens has emerged as a frequent big-game performer since joining Dallas.
- Cowherd and Middlekauff argue Pickens' production makes him extension-worthy despite Jerry Jones' usual reluctance to pay early.
Dak's Leadership Sparked The Comeback
- Colin recounts Dak Prescott's leadership in rallying Dallas from 21-0 down to win 24-21.
- He credits Prescott's locker-room intangibles and clutch mentality for the 24 unanswered points comeback.

