In this discussion, economist Noah Smith, known for his insights on economic policy and authoring 'Noahpinion', dives into the shift from empirical studies to grand theories in economics. He critiques the evolving perception of the Economics Nobel Prize and its implications for the field. The conversation spans topics like the impact of AI on jobs, the historical lessons from North and South Korea’s differing economic journeys, and the often-overlooked importance of microeconomics over flashy macroeconomic theories.
The podcast emphasizes the ongoing shift in economics from theoretical frameworks to data-driven empirical research that addresses current challenges.
A significant debate is presented regarding AI's dual potential to displace jobs while also creating new employment opportunities in the future.
Deep dives
Turpentine's New Publication Launch
Turpentine is set to launch a new publication aimed at providing engaging written content from its notable hosts and expert guests. Early access is being offered to listeners, encouraging them to subscribe and stay updated on the latest developments. The publication will leverage ideas generated from group chats, ensuring a diverse range of topics and viewpoints will be presented. This initiative signifies Turpentine's commitment to enhance listener engagement beyond audio content.
Reflections on the Nobel Prize in Economics
The recent award of the 2024 Economics Nobel Prize reflects a significant shift in the field, moving toward empirical analysis and practical applications rather than solely theoretical contributions. Past winners often included theorists whose ideas had considerable cultural influence but lacked empirical validation. However, in recent years, the focus has shifted toward findings that are data-driven and relevant to current economic challenges. This evolution exemplifies a growing recognition of the importance of measurable outcomes in the discipline of economics.
Economic Theories and Their Real-World Impact
A historical overview reveals that many influential economic theories have not corresponded well with actual economic data, indicating a disconnect between theoretical models and reality. An example mentioned is the real business cycle theory, which attributes economic fluctuations primarily to changes in innovation rates. Critics argue that such theories, while popular, fail to adequately explain real-world phenomena and often rely on assumptions that do not hold up under scrutiny. This ongoing tension between theoretical models and empirical evidence raises questions about the validity and reliability of long-standing economic theories.
AI's Role in the Future of Labor Markets
The discourse surrounding AI's impact on job markets has intensified, with many experts weighing in on its potential to displace or create jobs. Historical patterns show that past technological advancements often fueled job creation rather than elimination, prompting skepticism about whether AI will be a true outlier in this regard. Critics of notable theorists argue that assumptions about automation's detrimental effects on employment overlook the possibility of new job categories emerging. This ongoing debate highlights the complexities associated with predicting AI's long-term effects on labor dynamics.
Noah Smith and Erik Torenberg tackle the shift in economic research from empirical studies to "big think" theories, critically examine Acemoglu's work on institutions and AI's impact on jobs, and debate the future of economics as a science. For full show notes, visit: https://highlightai.com/share/d1548747-43db-4b71-b0a8-af285d3deafd
Explore the art of high-stakes negotiations through fascinating stories and practical insights from world-renowned dealmakers and diplomats in Dealcraft: Insights from Great Negotiators, hosted by Harvard Business School professor Jim Sebenius.
📝Notion offers powerful workflow and automation templates, perfect for streamlining processes and laying the groundwork for AI-driven automation. With Notion AI, you can search across thousands of documents from various platforms, generating highly relevant analysis and content tailored just for you - try it for free at notion.com/upstreampod
💥 Head to Squad to access global engineering without the headache and at a fraction of the cost: head to https://choosesquad.com/ and mention “Turpentine” to skip the waitlist.