
In Bed With The Right Episode 112 -- The Natural Childbirth Movement
Dec 9, 2025
Dive into the complex history of the natural childbirth movement, exploring its evolution from eugenics in the 1930s to modern radical networks. Hear about real medical abuses that fuel distrust and alternative choices. The podcast critiques the romanticized ideal of 'natural' births while highlighting the risks of historical maternal and infant mortality. It even reflects on controversial figures like Ina May Gaskin and the impact of the Free Birth Society. Ultimately, it emphasizes the importance of prioritizing safety over ideology in childbirth.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Radicalization From Birth Trauma
- Many women's turn to the natural childbirth movement springs from real trauma and disrespect experienced in hospitals during labor and delivery.
- Moira Donegan argues the movement exploits legitimate grievances to push ideological alternatives to medical authority.
Counterculture Meets Conservatism
- The natural childbirth movement blends countercultural distrust of institutions with conservative ideas about women's roles and bodies.
- Adrian Daub and Moira Donegan describe it as both hippie aesthetic and politically reactionary.
What 'Natural' Typically Means
- 'Natural childbirth' primarily means avoiding pharmacological pain relief and interventions like C-sections or pitocin.
- The movement frames painlessness as a return to a purer, pre-industrial ideal of birth.











