Christine Rosen, a Senior Fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and author of "The Extinction of Experience," delves into how technology disconnects us from real experiences. She discusses the paradox of photographing moments yet missing them, and the rise of tech addiction affecting our relationships. Rosen emphasizes the importance of handwriting for cognitive and emotional growth, and argues for reclaiming genuine human connections amid a digital world. She also highlights spiritual practices as essential in countering modern distractions.
Modern technology mediates our experiences, causing a disconnect from reality that threatens our relationships and connections to nature.
The reliance on digital communication diminishes our ability to engage in face-to-face interactions, undermining social and emotional skills.
Rosen warns against reducing complex human emotions to data algorithms, which risks eliminating essential growth and understanding in relationships.
To reclaim our humanity, we must embrace human uncertainties and foster genuine experiences over the conveniences offered by technology.
Deep dives
The Role of Experience in a Digital World
The podcast discusses the concept introduced in Dr. Christine Rosen's book that modern technology often mediates our experiences, leading to a disconnect from the physical world. Rosen refers to Wendell Berry's poem to illustrate the idea of capturing experiences through technology while missing the essence of being present. This gradual erosion of direct interaction with reality threatens our sense of pleasure, relationships, and connection to nature. The conversation highlights the importance of recognizing how daily technology use impacts our experiences and encourages thoughtful engagement with the physical world.
Technological Awe and Its Consequences
The podcast examines the initial awe inspired by smartphones and other technologies, likening their impact to a slot machine that keeps users engaged. Rosen emphasizes that while technology provides convenience and connection, it simultaneously detracts from genuine human experiences. This shift leads to a more automated and detached interaction with life, and a growing reliance on devices to communicate simply diminishes our capacity for face-to-face engagement. The discussion concludes that this ongoing relationship with technology requires a deeper questioning of its value and implications for our humanity.
The Impact of Mediating Technology
Christine Rosen defines 'mediated technology' as any tool that creates a barrier between individuals and their lived experiences, calling for an examination of how these devices affect our human connections. She notes that as technology pervades every aspect of daily life, our ability to interact genuinely with one another is compromised, thus affecting social and emotional skills. The conversation sheds light on the important distinction between mediated and direct experiences, reinforcing that not all forms of communication through devices can replace true human connection. Rosen urges a re-evaluation of which human experiences we allow to be mediated and which we preserve in their original form.
Reviving Face-to-Face Communication
The podcast highlights the importance of face-to-face communication and the physiological understanding required to resolve conflicts and build relationships. Rosen argues that while digital interactions can suffice, they lack the richness and depth necessary for genuine understanding, which can lead to misunderstanding and tension. The reliance on technology has made skills of reading body language and non-verbal cues deteriorate, which Rosen finds concerning for future generations. Ultimately, the conversation advocates revitalizing face-to-face communication as a practice to foster empathy and understanding among individuals.
The Dangers of Outsourcing Emotion
Rosen discusses the perils of apps like People Keeper that propose to manage relationships based on emotional data derived from biometrics. This raises ethical concerns about reducing complex human emotions to mere algorithms, limiting our capacity to experience and understand one another. The podcast sheds light on how such technologies can promote a lack of judgment and critical thinking about our relationships. By outsourcing our emotional experiences, we risk becoming more machine-like, losing essential human growth and connection.
Humanism Against Technological Dominance
The podcast explores the need for a renaissance of humanism in response to the pervasive influence of technology and a scientistic worldview. Rosen argues that humanism should prioritize genuine human experiences over the efficiencies offered by technology. This shift would involve recognizing the value of human uncertainties and emotional complexities, rather than trying to eliminate them through technological mediation. The conversation emphasizes that embracing chances and the messiness of life is crucial to reclaiming our humanity amid advancing technology.
Finding Balance in Technology Use
The podcast concludes with recommendations on how to navigate the complexities of technology in our lives consciously. Participants discuss strategies like limiting phone use during mealtimes, engaging in analog activities, and fostering direct relationships to counteract the influences of mediated experiences. Raising awareness about the impact of technology on mental health, particularly among younger generations, is crucial for reclaiming a balanced existence. The collaborative effort to engage more meaningfully with each other and the world fosters a deeper understanding of presence and reality.
What happens when we live our lives through mediating technologies? We take countless pictures but don’t look at our kids. We film vacations but are never fully present. We search for answers online but rarely puzzle over the questions. And we distract ourselves from difficult emotions, but we never take on the cross-bearing work of the soul. In the early twentieth century, French Catholic novelist Georges Bernanos worried that such a superficial existence would create little more than “stumps of men.” Join me and Christine Rosen as we explore her book The Extinction of Experience on the Evangelization & Culture Podcast.
Stay up-to-date with the latest episodes of the Evangelization & Culture Podcast biweekly on WordOnFire.org, on YouTube, or wherever you get your podcasts.
You can get more content like this in the quarterly print journal of the Word on Fire Institute, Evangelization & Culture.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
