Alexander Herman, a legal scholar and author, dives into the heated debate over the Parthenon marbles and their rightful ownership. He explores the historical context of Lord Elgin's acquisition and the emotional toll on Greece. Herman also connects this issue to the looting of Cambodian artifacts, highlighting the cultural significance of repatriation. The discussion showcases changing attitudes toward cultural heritage and the moral complexities of ownership, urging a reconsideration of museum practices worldwide.
The podcast highlights the ongoing cultural dispute over the Parthenon marbles, questioning the ethical responsibilities of museums in artifact ownership.
It emphasizes a global shift in attitudes towards returning looted cultural heritage, as seen in Cambodia's demand for repatriation of stolen antiquities.
Deep dives
The Parthenon Marbles: A Cultural Custody Dispute
The Parthenon marbles, also known as the Elgin marbles, comprise approximately 90 large pieces taken from Athens in the early 19th century by Lord Elgin. This act has sparked one of the longest cultural custody disputes in history, with Greece seeking the return of these significant artifacts, which are now housed in the British Museum. The complexities of ownership are highlighted by differing claims: while the British Museum legally acquired the marbles, Greece argues that they were taken under a contract with a now-defunct empire. This ongoing debate raises broader questions about the ethical responsibilities of museums in managing artifacts removed from their countries of origin.
The Cultural Significance of the Marbles
For many Greeks, the Parthenon marbles symbolize a deep connection to their cultural heritage and national identity, relating to the glory of classical Athens. They are not merely historical objects but represent a source of pride and a link to a period of significant contributions to democracy, philosophy, and the arts. The British Museum, conversely, views the marbles as critical to its collection and an attraction for millions of visitors each year. This cultural conflict is underscored by the different values ascribed to the marbles by the two parties involved.
Shifts in Museum Practices and Public Pressure
In recent years, museums globally have begun to reassess their practices of acquiring relics, responding to increasing public pressure to return artifacts to their countries of origin. The British Museum has faced scrutiny regarding its ownership of the Parthenon marbles and is under pressure to consider a more collaborative relationship with Greece. As societal attitudes change, there is a growing recognition of the moral obligation museums have towards the artifacts in their collections. Events surrounding Cambodian antiquities emphasize this shift, showcasing how cultural objects are now viewed more as heritage rather than trophies.
Revisiting Historical Narratives and Ownership Claims
The historical narrative surrounding Lord Elgin's acquisition of the marbles has evolved, especially regarding the legality and morality of such actions taken during colonial times. Critics argue that such artifacts should be returned to their rightful contexts rather than remain in foreign institutions. The case of the Parthenon marbles reflects broader trends in historical accountability, as countries grapple with their pasts, colonial legacies, and the implications for modern ownership and cultural preservation. Both Greece and the British Museum must navigate these complex narratives while reconciling historical injustices and contemporary values.
In 2023, Anderson Cooper reported that a large number of antiquities in the Metropolitan Museum of Art's collection had come to the world-class museum by way of theft. Ancient art had been looted from Cambodian temples fifty years ago and the Cambodian Government wanted them back. But as Cooper discovered, returning the stolen goods was no simple matter – a lesson that another 60 Minutes correspondent had learned two decades prior.
In 2002, Ed Bradley traveled to Greece and England to cover a dispute that is hundreds of years old – whether the British Museum should return a collection of marble statues removed from the Parthenon back to Athens. This episode of 60 Minutes: A Second Look will examine why, more than 20 years later, that dispute remains deadlocked, and whether efforts like those by the Cambodian activists that Cooper profiled are changing the way we think about museums and the ownership of ancient art.
If you enjoyed this episode of "60 Minutes: A Second Look", find and follow the show on your favorite podcast app.