In this episode, Jamal and Mehmed discuss the Israel-Palestine conflict, focusing on the left's perspective of Zionism. They delve into the objective material conditions in Gaza, the plight of the Palestinian population, and the brutal response of the Israeli state. They also analyze US and Israeli foreign policy, the influence of the Israel lobby, the shifting dynamics in the Middle East, and the potential for labor organizing. Overall, they explore the need for a class-first approach to the conflict.
Support for Israel is declining in the US, particularly among younger generations, reflecting a growing awareness of the Palestinian perspective.
American foreign policy decision-making in the Middle East has led to unintended consequences and a decline in American influence, particularly in relation to Iran.
The events in Israel and Palestine highlight a shift in regional power dynamics and the inability of the US and Israel to comprehend and adapt to the new geopolitical realities.
The American left can advocate for change by calling for a ceasefire and focusing on domestic issues to mobilize support and challenge current foreign policy decisions.
Deep dives
Lack of American support for Israeli actions
Recent events have led to a drop in support for Israel in the United States, particularly among younger generations. Polling shows that a majority of the American population opposes sending weapons to Israel and supports sending humanitarian aid to Palestinians. Calls for a ceasefire are gaining traction, despite being supported by a minority of Congress members. This shift in public sentiment reflects a declining consensus for unstinting support for Israel and a growing awareness of the Palestinian perspective.
Incompetence of American Foreign Policy
The events in Israel and Palestine highlight the incompetence and decay of American foreign policy decision-making. The US's ill-conceived interventions in the Middle East have yielded unintended consequences, allowing Iran to gain influence in the region while undermining Israel's position. The US is woefully unprepared for a military confrontation with Iran and the American public has little appetite for war. American elites' irrational support for Israel has led to increasingly desperate attempts to enforce this consensus, despite growing public opposition.
Shift in Regional Power Dynamics
The events in Israel and Palestine mark a shift in regional power dynamics and highlight America's declining influence. Israel's attempts to establish peaceful relations with Saudi Arabia were derailed by Hamas' actions, leading to closer ties between Saudi Arabia and Iran. The changing balance of power, coupled with US decline as a global hegemon, is causing disorientation among Western elites. The US and Israel's response to the situation reflects their inability to comprehend and adapt to the new geopolitical realities in the region.
Strategic Approach: Focus on Labor Politics
In advocating for change, the American left can play a supporting role by calling for a ceasefire and promoting a shift in focus away from unquestioning support for Israel. However, to effectively challenge the status quo, the left should emphasize issues that resonate with the American population, such as the decaying infrastructure, economic struggles, and the need to address labor concerns. By highlighting the misallocation of resources towards foreign military aid, the left can mobilize support and expose the irrationality of current foreign policy decisions.
The Urgent Crisis and Mobilizing Voters
The podcast episode discusses the urgent crisis in Palestine, with thousands of people dying and a collapsing support for Biden. The speaker emphasizes the importance of mobilizing voters and the possibilities of utilizing an outsider strategy in response to the ongoing crisis. They highlight the need for both online activism and traditional organizing, recognizing the importance of grassroots efforts in achieving political change.
Changing Dynamics and Left-Liberal Convergence
The podcast explores the changing dynamics in the United States regarding support for Israel. They note that the popular shift away from support for Israel is not the result of propaganda, but rather a reaction to the growing mistrust in mainstream media. They highlight the divergence between American Jews and Israelis on the issue, with American Jews increasingly moving left. The podcast also discusses how support for Palestinians provides an opportunity for left and liberal convergence, creating potential for a class-focused politics and alliances that challenge mainstream political consensus.
Potential Resolutions and Regional Implications
The podcast raises questions about the potential resolutions to the crisis in Palestine and the wider implications for the region. They discuss the possibility of a two-state solution or a single state with free and fair elections. They also highlight that Israel's military advantage is not invulnerable, as they face potential regional coalition forces and diminishing geopolitical reliance. The podcast stresses the need for the Israeli population to confront the reality of their situation and explores the potential for a broader wave of revolutions in the Middle East as a response to ongoing conflicts.
Hello friends! In this episode of Transmissions, we discuss the recent events unfolding in the Israel-Palestine conflict. In typical Class Unity spirit, we try to focus on the question of what it might mean to approach this conflict from a class first perspective. A central theme of the episode is the question of how the […]
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
