In a riveting discussion, Jennifer Fleetwood, a Senior Lecturer in Criminology, and Louise Wattis, an Assistant Professor focusing on true crime narratives, dive into our obsession with crime stories. They explore how personal accounts from criminals are reshaping the public’s understanding of crime, raising questions about the reliability of these narratives. They also examine the allure of 'hard man' biographies, particularly among men, and dissect the ethical complexities of portraying violence and masculinity in modern media.
The surge in autobiographies by criminals highlights a shift in societal fascination with personal crime narratives, impacting public perceptions.
True crime media's rise facilitates open dialogue around crime experiences but raises ethical concerns regarding the glorification of violence.
Deep dives
The Rise of Crime Autobiographies
The proliferation of autobiographies by criminals reflects a cultural phenomenon where personal narratives take center stage in depicting crime. Over the years, bookstores and streaming platforms have become saturated with first-person accounts from prisoners, victims, and law enforcement, indicating a growing societal fascination with these stories. This trend raises important questions about why individuals feel compelled to share their experiences and how these narratives serve to shape public perception about crime. Jennifer Fleetwood, a criminologist, emphasizes the need to understand the cultural-historical context surrounding these storytelling trends, as they both contribute to and complicate the discourse on crime.
Compelling Stories of Victims and Criminals
In examining various crime narratives, several notable cases illustrate the complexities involved in personal storytelling within the criminal realm. For instance, Mo Farah's powerful documentary detailing his experiences of human trafficking allowed him to reclaim his identity and reshape his narrative, eliciting a strong public response. Howard Marks, a notorious drug smuggler, presented an unrepentant and charismatic portrayal of his life through his autobiography, reflecting both personal motivations and broader societal allure surrounding his criminal exploits. These narratives not only provide insights into the individuals involved but also reveal the diverse reactions and implications for public understanding of crime.
The Impact of True Crime on Society
The rise of true crime media, including podcasts and documentaries, has transformed the way society engages with stories about crime and its perpetrators. These platforms offer a unique opportunity for individuals, both victims and criminals, to share their experiences without significant censorship, creating a more nuanced dialogue about crime and its implications. However, this trend can also lead to a problematic glorification of violence and an ambiguous relationship with ethical storytelling, as seen in the genre's often exploitative nature. While some narratives contribute to a sense of justice and understanding, there is a risk that others perpetuate harmful stereotypes and cultural ideals surrounding masculinity and violence.
Laurie Taylor explores the fascination for true crime stories. He's joined by Jennifer Fleetwood, Senior Lecturer in Criminology at City, University of London, whose latest work considers the remarkable rise in the number of people who speak publicly about their experience of crime. Personal accounts used to be confined to the police station and the courtroom, but today bookshops heave with autobiographies by prisoners, criminals, police and barristers while streaming platforms host hours of interviews so how easy is it for the 'truth' to come out?
Louise Wattis, Assistant Professor in the Department: Social Sciences ·at Northumbria University, Newcastle looks at the skyrocketing interest in true crime as a form of popular entertainment. What do we know about the appeal of 'Hardman' biographies of violent criminals, a hugely popular subgenre, particularly for male readers?
Producer: Jayne Egerton
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode