Congressional correspondent Deirdre Walsh delves into how members of Congress and their families trade stock. The podcast explores ETFs tracking lawmakers' investments, the ethics of mimicking their strategies, and a reindeer outperforming politicians in stock-picking. Hosts experiment with congressional stock investments, advocating for a ban on individual stock trading by Congress members.
ETFs Nance and Cruz mimic Congress members' stock preferences, revealing divided party investments.
Proposed 'Ending Trading and Holdings in Congressional Stocks Act' aims to prohibit lawmakers from individual stock trading.
Deep dives
ETFs Modeled After Congress Trades
A trader created ETFs based on trades by members of Congress, using publicly available disclosure forms to mirror Democratic and Republican lawmakers' investment strategies. The ETFs, Nance and Cruz, reflect the different parties' holdings, with Nance showing Democratic preferences for software and pharmaceuticals, while Cruz leans towards oil and gas companies. Despite performance variations, questions arise on lawmakers potentially using inside information for market gains.
Calls to Restrict Congressional Stock Trading
Advocates propose banning individual stock trading by members of Congress to avoid conflicts of interest and insider trading perceptions. The 'Ending Trading and Holdings in Congressional Stocks Act' aims to restrict such activities, allowing investments in market-wide funds but not in individual companies. Trust in government decisions remains low, prompting scrutiny on politicians benefiting disproportionately from stock trading.
Comparing Congressional and Reindeer Stock Picking
Research indicates that congressional stock trading does not significantly outperform the market, with academics suggesting performance on par with random stock picks. In a curious study, reindeer selecting stocks outperformed congresspeople, highlighting the unpredictability of stock market outcomes. Insights like these challenge assumptions about lawmakers' investment success and raise awareness about the ethics of stock trading by public figures.
Our friends at the Indicator from Planet Money caught up with congressional correspondent Deirdre Walsh to talk about her reporting on how members of Congress and their families trade stock. Then, in classic style, the Indicator team tried their hands at doing so themselves.
We will be back in your feeds Friday with the weekly roundup.