
On the Nose The Inheritance of Defeat
Oct 29, 2026
Molly Crabapple, artist and political writer; Harriet Clark, author and organizer; and Irena Klepfisz, poet, activist, and scholar, explore what radical Jews inherit from family and movement ancestors. They discuss Bundist memory, lesbian feminist organizing, prison communities, coalition politics, mourning, Holocaust memory, and how defeat can shape new forms of collective life.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Build Institutions When Doors Stay Closed
- The Bund responded to exclusion by building schools, libraries, medical centers, magazines, distribution networks, and bookstores.
- Klepfisz carried this practical model into lesbian feminism by creating institutions instead of repeatedly seeking admission.
Defeat Is Not Always Failure
- Defeat does not necessarily mean failure; movements can lose because greater forces overpower them.
- The Bund’s defeat reflected Western abandonment, while contemporary organizers also confront the demoralizing experience of losing despite public support.
Preserve The Fire Through Defeat
- Keep building justice, beauty, kindness, and solidarity even when powerful forces prevail.
- Molly Crabapple argues that movements preserve ideas through continued practice; those ideas can reemerge when conditions change.







