070 The Fate of the Persecutors of the Prophet Joseph Smith
Jul 2, 2024
auto_awesome
The podcast explores the fates of those involved in the persecution of Joseph Smith, questioning the accuracy of morbid stories of divine retribution. It delves into the lack of justice for the murders of Joseph and Hyrum Smith, highlighting discrepancies between popular tales and historical facts. Stories of tragic ends for some persecutors are contrasted with the normal lives led by others, sparking reflection on the impact of these events.
The podcast questions the historical accuracy of divine retribution tales on Joseph Smith's persecutors.
The lack of justice in holding the murderers of Joseph and Hiram Smith accountable is discussed.
Witness credibility in the trial of Joseph Smith raises doubts about the pursuit of justice.
Deep dives
Doubtful Historicity of Vengeful Narratives
The episode delves into the publication 'The Fate of the Persecutors of the Prophet Joseph Smith' and questions the historical accuracy of the morbid tales of divine retribution on persecutors of Joseph Smith. These stories, although captivating, are mostly unsupported by credible evidence, relying on hearsay rather than factual records. The episode raises concerns about the reliability of such narratives and challenges their status as legendary folklore rather than documented accounts, prompting a critical examination of the actual fate of those involved in Joseph's persecution.
Thwarted Quest for Justice
The podcast discusses the lack of justice in holding the perpetrators of Joseph and Hiram Smith's murders accountable. Despite Governor Thomas Ford's assertion of seeking justice for the crime, the trial proceedings revealed a complex interplay of factors inhibiting convictions. Key evidence from witnesses is discredited by the prosecutor himself, casting doubt on the validity of the testimonies and raising questions about the pursuit of truth amidst political and societal tensions.
Redefining Testimonies and Questionable Witnesses
The episode explores the credibility of witnesses like Eliza Graham and Benjamin Brackenberry, whose accounts of the murders paint a damning portrait of the culprits. However, prosecutor Josiah Lamborn surprisingly disavows their testimonies, citing inconsistencies and their unreliability. The strategic withdrawal of crucial witness statements adds a perplexing twist to the trial, leaving the pursuit of justice in the aftermath of Joseph and Hiram's deaths shrouded in uncertainty and intrigue.
The Unresolved Case of Joseph Smith's Trial
The trial of Joseph Smith showcases a lack of justice and integrity, with Browning dismantling the evidence and the jury swiftly returning a not guilty verdict. Suspicions arise around potential threats or bribery, highlighting the trial's biased and orchestrated nature. Despite good evidence and witness disavowals, the mob leaders go free, revealing a corrupt legal system favoring the persecutors.
Controversies Surrounding the Burials of Joseph and Hiram Smith
The burial locations of Joseph and Hiram Smith remain a mystery, with Emma's protective actions leading to secretive relocations of the bodies. Various burial sites include the Nauvoo House, Smith land, and the Homestead property. Even after reidentification attempts and grave markers, historians and researches dispute the accuracy of their burial spots, adding layers of complexity and uncertainty to their final resting places.
In 1952 book entitled, The Fate of the Persecutors of the Prophet Joseph Smith, was published by N. B. Lundwall. Within its pages, among other things, Lundwall presented various stories describing how many of those who played significant roles in the persecution of Joseph Smith met with unfortunate ends in unnatural and sometimes gruesome ways, underscoring the idea of divine justice and retribution. Unfortunately, the historical credibility of most of these stories is seriously lacking since they are based on unverifiable hearsay rather than well-documented and corroborated records. These morbid tales are thus the stuff of legend and folklore rather than a robust documentary record. But they do stimulate the question: What do we know about what actually happened to those involved in the deaths of Joseph and Hyrum Smith? Were they ever brought to justice? Did they live long lives? Did any of them meet a tragic mortal end?
In this episode of Church History Matters, we investigate the answers to these questions based primarily in the solid historical research of Marvin S. Hill and Dallin H. Oaks.