Vivian Schiller, former head of news at Twitter and current executive director of Aspen Digital, joins the discussion on the complex landscape of free speech online. She delves into Elon Musk's controversial claims and Mark Zuckerberg's decision to end fact-checking on Meta platforms, enhancing concerns over misinformation. The conversation also touches on the feeling of censorship within conservative circles and the ongoing struggle to balance free speech with responsible content moderation. It’s a revealing look at how tech giants shape public discourse.
Elon Musk's influence on political discourse raises concerns about wealthy individuals shaping narratives in democracies while free speech is increasingly at risk.
The transition from traditional fact-checking to community-based moderation by social media platforms poses challenges for controlling misinformation in public discourse.
Deep dives
The Role of Free Speech in Democracy
The discussion emphasizes the critical nature of free speech as an essential component of functioning democracies. Elon Musk’s assertion that 'free speech is the bedrock of a functioning democracy' sparks debate over the implications of wealthy individuals influencing political discourse in other countries. The conversation also explores the tension between free speech and the potential spread of misinformation, particularly in sensitive contexts like the discussion surrounding grooming gangs. Through Musk's involvement and subsequent reactions from political figures, it becomes evident that the dynamics of free speech are increasingly complex in the age of social media.
The Influence of Social Media Giants
The conversation highlights the pivotal role of social media platforms, particularly Twitter, now rebranded as X under Musk's ownership, in shaping public discourse. The discussion references a shift in content moderation policies, where traditional fact-checking is being replaced by community-based moderation or 'community notes.' This transition raises concerns about the potential for unchecked misinformation and the responsibilities of social media companies in maintaining truthful and transparent platforms. Mark Zuckerberg's parallel changes at Meta further illustrate a broader trend among social media leaders to adapt to these debates over free expression.
Political Manipulation and Public Opinion
The episode examines how political figures leverage social media narratives to influence public opinion and political conversations. Various politicians, including those from opposition parties, are shown to echo Musk’s sentiments, thereby solidifying his influence on public discourse. The discussion reveals the precarious balance that politicians must maintain to avoid alienating influential figures like Musk while also addressing serious societal issues, such as the victims of sexual abuse. This manipulation of narratives by powerful individuals underscores a troubling aspect of democratic functioning in the contemporary landscape.
The Dichotomy of Information and Responsibility
The conversation addresses the dichotomy between free expression and responsible information dissemination in the context of social media platforms. While community notes offer a way for users to provide context to contentious statements, the effectiveness of this approach in combating misinformation remains questionable. The episode argues for the necessity of both community moderation and traditional fact-checking mechanisms to support informed public discourse. Ultimately, the discussion leaves listeners contemplating whether current models of free speech are sustainable and beneficial for democratic societies.
The billionaire owner of X has made misleading claims about Keir Starmer’s handling of the grooming gangs scandal and Meta boss Mark Zuckerberg has announced the end of independent fact-checking on Meta’s platforms in the US. The move comes as Zuckerberg and other tech executives seek to improve relations with US President-elect Donald Trump before he takes office later this month.
In this episode Amol and Nick talk to Vivian Schiller, former head of news at Twitter, about what is happening to free speech online. They also reflect on how Prime Minister Keir Starmer, the Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch and the Reform UK leader Nigel Farage have reacted to Elon Musk’s intervention.
To get Amol and Nick's take on the biggest stories and insights from behind the scenes at the UK's most influential radio news programme make sure you hit subscribe on BBC Sounds. That way you’ll get an alert every time we release a new episode, and you won’t miss our extra bonus episodes either.
GET IN TOUCH:
* Send us a message or a voice note via WhatsApp to +44 330 123 4346
* Email today@bbc.co.uk
The Today Podcast is hosted by Amol Rajan and Nick Robinson who are both presenters of BBC Radio 4’s Today programme. Amol was the BBC’s media editor for six years and is the former editor of the Independent, he’s also the current presenter of University Challenge. Nick has presented the Today programme since 2015, he was the BBC’s political editor for ten years before that and also previously worked as ITV’s political editor.
This episode was made by Lewis Vickers with Nadia Gyane and Grace Reeve. Digital production was by Nadia Gyane. The technical producer was Jonny Baker. The editor is Louisa Lewis. The executive producer is Owenna Griffiths.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode