Episode 41 - Do data centers truly bring economic benefits to their location? With Max Schulze, SDIA
Sep 28, 2023
auto_awesome
Max Schulze, Co-founder of SDIA, discusses the challenges of quantifying the economic benefits of data centers. They explore the positive impacts data centers have on local businesses, taxation issues faced by owners, and the need for a global organization in digital economics. The conversation highlights the absence of definitive conclusions regarding the economic impact and proposes a specialized economic model for the industry. It emphasizes the importance of considering non-monetary values when attracting data centers to municipalities.
Determining the economic value of data centers requires comprehensive cost-benefit analysis that considers socialized costs and revenue generation challenges.
Differentiating between regional data centers and global infrastructure is crucial to understand the local advantages and strategic placement of data centers.
Deep dives
The Economic Value of Data Centers
Determining the economic value of data centers is a complex task. While it is easy to recognize the job creation and local material purchases during construction, understanding the revenue generation and tax implications once the data center is operational is challenging. Municipalities often see data centers as a positive development due to low traffic, noise, and pollution impact, along with property tax benefits. However, there is a lack of comprehensive cost-benefit analysis that considers the socialized costs of building grid infrastructure and water supply. Moreover, the challenge extends to global companies that structure themselves to optimize tax payments, making it unclear how to account for the revenue generated in a particular country.
Regional Data Centers and Global Infrastructure
Differentiating between regional data centers and global infrastructure is important. Regional data centers, serving local businesses and municipalities, can bring numerous benefits, such as improved IT infrastructure, efficiency, and tangible value to the community. On the other hand, large-scale data centers driven by global cloud providers may not deliver the same local advantages. Embracing regionality and considering the value brought by IT professionals who support local digitalization efforts is crucial. For global infrastructure, a need arises for a global planning approach to strategically place data centers, considering resilience, environmental impact, and spreading benefits across society.
The Need for New Economic Models and Global Collaboration
To assess the economic value of data centers accurately, new economic models need to be developed. These models should go beyond traditional metrics like property taxes and address the societal and environmental impacts. Academia and professionals specializing in such models seem essential for this task. Furthermore, global collaboration is required to establish a global framework for digital economics. This framework should account for the flows of economic value in a borderless digital world and balance the optimization of services with regional benefits. While the challenge is complex, understanding the value, both monetary and non-monetary, that data centers bring to communities is key to making informed decisions about their development.
Data centers have outgrown their anonymity. They are large enough consumers of energy and space, that they have to enter the political landscape and justify their existence. But how do we know if a data really brings benefits to its location?
In some places (like London), it appears that they soak up grid connection capacity and block housing projects. In others (like Denmark and Ireland) they use renewable energy and jeopardize local decarbonization targets.
It's not easy to know the net benefits brought by a data center, because much of what it does is in the virtual world, and is delivered to people far away.
Max Schulze has some thoughts on how to start working out the real benefits of a data center - and we hope for more input from DCD readers and listeners.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode