Hotel Bar Sessions Peer Review
Jul 26, 2024
The hosts dive into the controversies surrounding academic peer review, revealing inconsistencies that undermine research quality. They examine biases among reviewers and the implications for academic integrity. Discussion includes the current retraction crisis and challenges faced in specialized fields. The conversation also tackles the pros and cons of double-blind reviews, exploring the need for accountability and transparency. They emphasize reforms to enhance scientific integrity and ponder the future of the peer review process.
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
1 2 3 4 5 6
Intro
00:00 • 3min
Unpacking the Peer Review Crisis
03:15 • 18min
Navigating Sponsorship and the Peer Review Crisis
21:34 • 2min
Reevaluating the Peer Review Process: Challenges and Opportunities
23:11 • 5min
Navigating Double-Blind Peer Review
27:44 • 7min
Addressing Bias in Peer Review
34:56 • 19min