Donald Trump, the former President of the U.S., is known for his controversial plans to slash the federal workforce and consolidate power. Huey Long, the autocratic former Governor of Louisiana, serves as a historical backdrop, illustrating how charismatic leaders can manipulate systems for personal gain. The conversation delves into tactics like electoral manipulation and media censorship, reflecting on Long's legacy and the implications for democracy today. The parallels drawn paint a worrying picture of authoritarian trends emerging in American governance.
Donald Trump's plan to eliminate federal workers if re-elected reflects a historical pattern of consolidating power seen in past autocracies.
The parallels between Huey Long's tactics and contemporary political maneuvers demonstrate the potential resurgence of authoritarian practices in the U.S.
Deep dives
State Capture and Authoritarianism
State capture occurs when institutions intended to serve the public are manipulated to benefit those in power, creating an environment of fear among citizens. In the case of Poland, an autocratic populist party exploited legitimate electoral victories to replace civil servants with loyalists, thus consolidating power. This manipulation extended to using state institutions to finance party members and targeted political rivals through the tax and legal systems, leading to accusations of state-backed harassment. The story parallels historical examples, like Huey Long in Louisiana, who crafted a playbook for capturing governmental processes for personal gain.
The Tactics of Autocrats
Huey Long demonstrated a recognized path to authoritarianism by capturing the legislature, intimidating judges, and using propaganda to maintain power. His rise hinged on manipulating elections, engaging in smear campaigns against opponents, and employing violent tactics when necessary. Long also curtailed media freedom, effectively employing censorship and creating an environment where dissent was met with force. This method of governance highlights the alarming potential for authoritarian tactics to re-emerge in contemporary systems, particularly the rising trend of normalizing drastic changes to governance without public consent.
Echoes of Authoritarianism in Modern Politics
Current political dynamics expose vulnerabilities in the United States' checks and balances system, where leaders can exploit democratic processes to gain authoritarian control. For instance, proposals to manipulate federal agencies reflect patterns seen in historical authoritarian regimes, risking the independence of crucial governmental functions. Additionally, the possibility of using military forces for political gains raises concerns about democracy's health, as historical missteps echo in modern scenarios. Such actions create alarming parallels between historic autocratic practices and present-day political maneuvers that could threaten democratic principles.
Donald Trump has vowed to eliminate hundreds of workers across federal agencies if he becomes president again. Consolidating power and placing friends in key roles are textbook autocratic maneuvers, but they also are not new in the United States. This episode revisits the story of Louisiana Governor Huey Long, who sought to take over the apparatus of government in his state, just as illiberal leaders have done in other countries.
Autocracy in America is produced by The Atlantic and made possible with support from the SNF Agora Institute at Johns Hopkins University, an academic and public forum dedicated to strengthening global democracy through powerful civic engagement and informed, inclusive dialogue.
Music in this episode by Tellsonic (“Time Traveller,” “Desert Whispers”), Spectacles Wallet and Watch (“Secret Agents”), Howard Harper-Barnes (“Mysterious Forest”), J. F. Gloss (“Mysterious Figures”), Luella Gren (“Sleep Forever”), Ruiqi Zhao (“Ancient Spells”), and Rob Smierciak (“Mystery March”).
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.