Exploring the story of Pope Joan, a female pope who disguised herself as a man and rose to power in the 9th century. Discussing the unusual circumstances of her pregnancy and birth, the controversy surrounding her existence, and the fascination with the masculinity of the Pope. Delving into the question of why women cannot become Pope in the Catholic Church and exploring the paradoxical portrayal of women in the Church.
49:33
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The legend of Pope Joan serves as a cautionary tale about the perceived threat of femininity in positions of power within the Catholic Church and highlights the patriarchal nature of the church hierarchy.
The legend of Pope Joan reflects the deeply entrenched gender roles and misogyny within medieval Christian society, challenging the established patriarchal structure of the church and underscoring the fear of female power and anxiety surrounding the feminization of the priestly role.
Deep dives
The Legend of Pope Joan
The legend of Pope Joan tells the story of a female pope who disguised herself as a man and eventually became pope. The story originated in the early 13th century and gained traction over the centuries. While the historical accuracy of Pope Joan's existence is highly doubtful, the legend serves as a cautionary tale about the perceived threat of femininity in positions of power within the Catholic Church and highlights the patriarchal nature of the church hierarchy.
The Influence of Gender Roles and Misogyny
The legend of Pope Joan reflects the deeply entrenched gender roles and misogyny within medieval Christian society. Women were traditionally seen as inferior to men, and the idea of a woman assuming the role of a pope challenged the established patriarchal structure of the church. The story underscores both the fear of female power and the anxiety surrounding the feminization of the priestly role, as celibacy and priestly duties were viewed as traditionally masculine.
The Contradictory Views of Female Spirituality
While the legend of Pope Joan embodies the anxieties and prejudices of the time, it is important to note that there were alternative views on female spirituality within Christian theology. The veneration of female saints, such as Catherine of Siena, demonstrates a recognition of women's holiness and their ability to embody divine virtues. However, these alternate views did not challenge the deeply entrenched male-dominated structure of the church.
The Unlikelihood of Female Popes in the Church
Given the Catholic Church's adherence to traditional gender roles and the interpretation of biblical texts, it is highly unlikely that women will be allowed to become priests or hold positions of power within the church in the foreseeable future. The theological justifications for excluding women from these roles remain deeply ingrained in Catholic doctrine and tradition.
A Pope of great renown once reigned during chaotic years for the medieval Church: she was an extraordinary figure, from a time when women were forbidden from even becoming priests - indeed she is History’s only female Pope. But did this “Popess" really exist, and if so, who was this mysterious, awesome woman? What does her story reveal about the murky politics of the medieval Vatican? The original account described an English woman named Joan, who through her brilliance rose to become none other than Pope John VIII. Then, in a shocking turn of events, she fell pregnant and gave birth to a son during a procession, before meeting a sinister end…
Join Tom and Dominic as they discuss this most remarkable of legends and discover the truth behind the story of the pregnant Pope - a tale of teenage Popes, female persecution, blinding, castration, and Europe’s greatest revolution.