In the Arena: The Debates and Lectures of William Lane Craig

Christianity vs. Scientific Naturalism

Sep 19, 2025
Garrett Hardin, an ecologist and philosopher known for his work on population and ethics, debates William Lane Craig on the clash between Christianity and scientific naturalism. They discuss the limits of science in proving metaphysical claims, examine Hardin's skepticism about God's existence, and explore the implications of objective morality. The conversation deepens with audience questions about abortion, scripture, and the afterlife, highlighting challenges to fine-tuning arguments and the concept of God. Hardin's agnostic perspective adds a thought-provoking layer to the discourse.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
INSIGHT

Limits Of Scientific Naturalism

  • William Lane Craig argues scientific naturalism is self-refuting because it insists we only believe what can be scientifically proven.
  • He contends many truths (math, ethics, metaphysics) are rational despite being unprovable by science.
INSIGHT

Big Bang Points To A First Cause

  • Craig presents the Big Bang as evidence the universe began to exist and therefore requires a cause beyond space and time.
  • He infers a timeless, immaterial, uncaused cause fits the notion of God.
INSIGHT

Fine-Tuning And Design Argument

  • Craig cites fine-tuning of physical constants as strong evidence for design because life-permitting values are extraordinarily improbable.
  • He argues design is more plausible than chance given incomprehensible odds against life-friendly initial conditions.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app