Intelligence Squared The Sunday Debate: Charles III should be the last British monarch
Apr 30, 2023
In a thought-provoking debate, Graham Smith, CEO of Republic and fervent advocate for democratic reform, argues that King Charles III should be the last British monarch. He challenges the monarchy's relevance in contemporary society. Opposing him is Robert Hardman, a royal commentator and author, who defends the monarchy's historical significance and its role in national stability. The discussion dives into generational attitudes, potential constitutional changes, and visions for a parliamentary democracy, unraveling the future of Britain's royal heritage.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Monarchy's Modern Relevance
- Robert Hardman recounts King Charles's state visit to Germany.
- The visit demonstrated the monarchy's modern relevance and soft power.
Soft Power Challenged
- Graham Smith challenges the "soft power" argument, citing a lack of evidence.
- He argues royal visits may damage the UK's influence, citing William and Edward's Caribbean tour.
Monarchy's Economic Value
- Robert Hardman cites Brand Finance, valuing the monarchy at £1.7 billion annually.
- He argues the monarchy's value outweighs its cost, citing media attention and diplomatic gatherings.
