Shabbat Behar-B'chukotai: The Lesson of Lessons
May 11, 2021
A reflective sermon explores suffering, free will, and the limits of blaming victims. It contrasts questions of how and to what end, urging a shift from why to what now. Stories and moral prompts challenge listeners to consider practical responses and character-shaping actions in the face of tragedy.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Fiddler Scene Frames The Question Of Suffering
- Rabbi Aaron Flanzraich recounts the Fiddler on the Roof scene where the sheriff warns Tevye of a pogrom but cannot stop it.
- Tevye's cry to God, "Couldn't you choose someone else every once in a while?" frames the problem of undeserved suffering.
Punishment Narrative Breaks Down With Extreme Tragedy
- The Torah portion treats many misfortunes as punishments, which can lead people to explain tragedies as deserved.
- Rabbi Aaron Flanzraich warns this mindset quickly becomes absurd when applied to events like child deaths or the Holocaust.
Hebrew Contrast Reframes 'Why' As 'To What'
- Hebrew distinguishes two questions: eich (how) asks about mechanics, while lama (from le+ma) asks 'to what', meaning what now.
- Rabbi Aaron Flanzraich emphasizes translation is interpretation and lama reframes inquiry from explanation to purpose.


