Keep or Kut - Pete (@PeteBBaseball) and Chad (@chadyoung) drafted their 2023 Keeper League All Stars. The rules were simple: ignoring rookies and prospects, draft a C, MI, CI, OF, SP, and RP who look to have excellent keeper value going forward based on 2023 NFBC ADP results. The final rosters were...

Pete:

C - Sean Murphy

CI - Yandy Díaz

MI - Ketel Marte

OF - Jarren Duran

SP - Mitch Keller

RP - Carlos Estévez

Chad:

C - Jonah Heim

CI - Josh Naylor

MI - Isaac Paredes

OF - Christian Yelich

SP - Brayan Bello

RP - Alexis Díaz

Join Pitcher List Plus and get an ad-free website and access to the Pitcher List Discord community, while supporting the podcast.

Timestamps

7:09 - The Keeper All Star draft kicks off with Pete taking Mitch Keller

13:50 - Chad took Jonah Heim with his first pick of the draft

19:56 - Chad loves the upside of Alexis Díaz and his ADP of 150

24:17 - Pete thinks Ketel Marte could be a really valuable keeper, even as he approaches the wrong-side of 30

28:15 - Out of Marte, Heim, Keller, and Díaz, who would Chad want to have the most on his Underdog Sports 7th Inning Stretch roster?

31:01 - Pete's favorite pick of the draft: Jarren Duran! With an ADP of 672, there is a lot to love here

35:33 - Josh Naylor has been on fire this season, and Chad was happy to secure him as his CI for this draft

39:46 - A second Red Sox is off the board. This time: Brayan Bello to Chad

44:09 - Pete isn't quite buying that Yandy Díaz is all of a sudden a power hitter, but he does like him enough to make him his CI

48:24 - Carlos Estévez was not a very exciting pick, despite the success he has had so far this season

53:17 - Chad has been all in on Isaac Paredes for awhile, and he is reaping the rewards this season

55:54 - Is Christian Yelich back?

0:01:53 - The final pick of the draft: Sean Murphy to Pete

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts |

#256 RET feat. guest Andrew Marquis