Killer Psyche

Arthur Gary Bishop: The Mormon Murderer

21 snips
Jan 27, 2026
A retired FBI profiler unpacks the chilling case of a trusted community member who hid a violent double life. The narrative follows a pattern of grooming, calculated abductions, and escalating murders. It traces early life, religious conflict, animal cruelty, and the shift from secrecy to deadly compulsion. The investigation, confession, trial, and final moments are all explored.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Abduction And First Murder

  • Arthur lured four-year-old Alonzo Daniels into his apartment with candy and toys before sexually touching and then drowning him in the bathtub.
  • He hid the body in his trunk and buried it in Utah's West Desert to avoid detection.
ANECDOTE

Gaining Access Through Grooming

  • Arthur ingratiated himself with a widow and gained custody of her son Jeff, then sexually abused him and used him to find other victims.
  • He later killed 11-year-old Kim Peterson near the same desert burial site where he hid Alonzo's body.
ANECDOTE

Confession Through Police Ruse

  • Detective Don Bell used a ruse to interview Jeff and then confronted Arthur, who eventually confessed to five murders on tape.
  • Bishop admitted his attraction to boys and said he would kill again if given the chance.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app