Theories of Everything with Curt Jaimungal
Joscha Bach on Intelligence, Existence, Time, and Consciousness
Episode guests
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
- Artists see art as a service that preserves the essence of consciousness.
- Efforts are being made to develop generalized algorithms that can efficiently explore solution spaces and discover patterns.
- Some individuals prioritize seeking truth through reasoning and problem-solving over emotional experiences.
- Consciousness is a control system that regulates actions based on perception, attention, and desired outcomes.
- Freedom and free will are related to our ability to make decisions based on internal models and desired goals.
Deep dives
The Purpose of Art as Seen by Artists
Artists perceive the purpose of art as capturing conscious states for its own sake, rather than as a means to another end. Artists see art as a service that is devoted to preserving the essence of consciousness.
Optimal Learning Algorithms
The quest for the optimal learning algorithm continues in the field of artificial intelligence. Generalized algorithms that can learn and adapt to a wide range of problems are being developed. The aim is to find algorithms that can efficiently explore solution spaces and discover patterns.
Embracing Ideas over Feelings
Some individuals, such as scientists, artists, and philosophers, may identify more strongly with their ideas and thoughts than their emotions and sensations. This can lead to a focus on seeking truth through reasoning and problem-solving rather than emotional experiences.
Consciousness as a Control System
Consciousness can be understood as a control system that regulates the organism's actions based on perception and the desired outcomes. It allows us to direct attention, make decisions, and create models of ourselves and the environment.
Freedom and Free Will
Freedom and free will are related to our ability to make decisions based on our internal models and desired outcomes. Freedom can be seen as the absence of compulsion, while free will is the ability to act according to our own goals and intentions.
Changing Identifications and Reframing
We have agency in shaping our identifications and the stories we tell ourselves. By reframing our experiences and changing our perspectives, we can alter how we perceive and react to different situations.
Importance of shifting focus on positive aspects of tasks
To experience positive emotions from tasks, it is important to focus on the aspects that bring sensory and aesthetic pleasure. By directing attention to pleasant sensations, such as the warmth of water or the movement of hands, one can derive enjoyment from even disliked tasks. Similarly, one can experience negative emotions by emphasizing the negative aspects of a task. Shifting focus to positive sensations enables the individual to find sensory and aesthetic pleasure in the task.
The complexity of consciousness and the self
Understanding consciousness requires investigating its underlying mechanisms, including attention and control. Consciousness is not a single, continuous entity, but a constructed experience of the mind. Dream states, for example, offer insights into the diverse aspects of consciousness. These dream states, which rely on perceptual models and attention control, allow for the exploration and prediction of sensory patterns. Consciousness is deeply connected to one's perception of reality and must be considered in relation to individual goals and identities.
The Role of Hyperorganism and Civilization
The podcast explores the concept of hyperorganism, suggesting that the invention of the concept of Jesus was a step towards humanizing hyperorganism. It suggests that humans have been selected to be part of hyperorganisms, leading to the feeling of being part of something larger than a tribe or family. The word 'God' was used to describe this civilization before enlightenment. The speaker highlights that gods are mental constructs, similar to selves, and Greek gods are seen as archetypes. The podcast emphasizes the importance of feeling connected to a greater whole and the danger of losing that connection.
The Loss of Future and Phantom Limb Effect
The podcast discusses the loss of future in society and the resulting loss of culture and spirituality. It explores the idea that humans have an innate need to be part of a culture that contributes to a sentient civilization, and losing that future creates a phantom limb effect. The speaker mentions the emergence of superstition and the need for people to feel connected to ideas like a conscious universe or immaterial deities. It distinguishes between the phantom limb of spirituality and the reality of life on the planet and society's role in organizing individuals as part of the ecosystem. The podcast touches on the importance of finding solutions to address social inequality and the challenges of implementing UBI and systemic incentives.
YouTube link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3MNBxfrmfmI
0:00:00 Introduction 0:00:17 Bach's work ethic / daily routine 0:01:35 What is your definition of truth? 0:04:41 Nature's substratum is a "quantum graph"? 0:06:25 Mathematics as the descriptor of all language 0:13:52 Why is constructivist mathematics "real"? What's the definition of "real"? 0:17:06 What does it mean to "exist"? Does "pi" exist? 0:20:14 The mystery of something vs. nothing. Existence is the default. 0:21:11 Bach's model vs. the multiverse 0:26:51 Is the universe deterministic 0:28:23 What determines the initial conditions, as well as the rules? 0:30:55 What is time? Is time fundamental? 0:34:21 What's the optimal algorithm for finding truth? 0:40:40 Are the fundamental laws of physics ultimately "simple"? 0:50:17 The relationship between art and the artist's cost function 0:54:02 Ideas are stories, being directed by intuitions 0:58:00 Society has a minimal role in training your intuitions 0:59:24 Why does art benefit from a repressive government? 1:04:01 A market case for civil rights 1:06:40 Fascism vs communism 1:10:50 Bach's "control / attention / reflective recall" model 1:13:32 What's more fundamental... Consciousness or attention? 1:16:02 The Chinese Room Experiment 1:25:22 Is understanding predicated on consciousness? 1:26:22 Integrated Information Theory of consciousness (IIT) 1:30:15 Donald Hoffman's theory of consciousness 1:32:40 Douglas Hofstadter's "strange loop" theory of consciousness 1:34:10 Holonomic Brain theory of consciousness 1:34:42 Daniel Dennett's theory of consciousness 1:36:57 Sensorimotor theory of consciousness (embodied cognition) 1:44:39 What is intelligence? 1:45:08 Intelligence vs. consciousness 1:46:36 Where does Free Will come into play, in Bach's model? 1:48:46 The opposite of free will can lead to, or feel like, addiction 1:51:48 Changing your identity to effectively live forever 1:59:13 Depersonalization disorder as a result of conceiving of your "self" as illusory 2:02:25 Dealing with a fear of loss of control 2:05:00 What about heart and conscience? 2:07:28 How to test / falsify Bach's model of consciousness 2:13:46 How has Bach's model changed in the past few years? 2:14:41 Why Bach doesn't practice Lucid Dreaming anymore 2:15:33 Dreams and GAN's (a machine learning framework) 2:18:08 If dreams are for helping us learn, why don't we consciously remember our dreams 2:19:58 Are dreams "real"? Is all of reality a dream? 2:20:39 How do you practically change your experience to be most positive / helpful? 2:23:56 What's more important than survival? What's worth dying for? 2:28:27 Bach's identity 2:29:44 Is there anything objectively wrong with hating humanity? 2:30:31 Practical Platonism 2:33:00 What "God" is 2:36:24 Gods are as real as you, Bach claims 2:37:44 What "prayer" is, and why it works 2:41:06 Our society has lost its future and thus our culture 2:43:24 What does Bach disagree with Jordan Peterson about? 2:47:16 The millennials are the first generation that's authoritarian since WW2 2:48:31 Bach's views on the "social justice" movement 2:51:29 Universal Basic Income as an answer to social inequality, or General Artificial Intelligence? 2:57:39 Nested hierarchy of "I"s (the conflicts within ourselves) 2:59:22 In the USA, innovation is "cheating" (for the most part) 3:02:27 Activists are usually operating on false information 3:03:04 Bach's Marxist roots and lessons to his former self 3:08:45 BONUS BIT: On societies problems
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
