England appoint Tuchel, as his old club Chelsea head to Liverpool
Oct 17, 2024
auto_awesome
Rory Smith, a celebrated football journalist, joins humorist Duncan Alexander, Premier League analyst Benji Lanyado, and German football expert Raphael Honigstein. They dive into the ramifications of Thomas Tuchel's appointment as England's manager, questioning the implications for local coaching. The conversation shifts to a thrilling Premier League preview, focusing on the high-stakes Liverpool vs Chelsea clash and new managerial techniques. They also share insights on unique strategies like Brentford's kick-off goal and critique the challenges of modern management.
The appointment of Thomas Tuchel as England's head coach has sparked debates about the value of hiring foreign managers in national teams.
Concerns about Tuchel's previous leadership experiences highlight the need for strong team cohesion and player connections in international football.
The discussion reflects a broader tension between pursuing immediate success with experienced coaches versus developing local talent for the future.
Deep dives
Apple Card Benefits for iPhone Users
Apple Card offers iPhone users enhanced privacy and security features, making it an attractive option for smartphone transactions. Users can earn daily cash back of up to 3% on all purchases, which encourages loyalty and increased usage of the card. Furthermore, this cash back can automatically earn interest if deposited into a high-yield savings account linked to the Apple Card. The convenience of applying for the Apple Card directly within the Wallet app streamlines the process for users.
Thomas Tuchel's Appointment as England Manager
The FA's decision to appoint Thomas Tuchel as the new England head coach marks a significant moment in English football, as it is only the third time in history that a foreign manager has taken on this role. Tuchel is scheduled to begin on January 1, 2025, and his tenure is being closely scrutinized amid debates about the implications of hiring a non-English manager. Critics argue that this choice reflects a failure to develop local talent within the coaching ranks, raising questions about the future of England's coaching pathways. The consensus among football analysts suggests that this move might prioritize immediate success over a long-term development strategy.
Concerns About Tuchel's Leadership Style
There are mixed feelings about Tuchel's leadership capabilities, especially concerning his previous experiences and how they might affect the England squad. Insights reveal that while Tuchel has showcased strong tactical acumen and success in short-term projects, his ability to build rapport and trust within a national team context is uncertain. The need for a manager who can connect with players, particularly when they are not training together regularly, is highlighted as crucial for his success. Observers note that Tuchel's past issues with team cohesion at Bayern Munich could be a warning sign for his upcoming national role.
Debate Over International Management Norms
The discussion about the acceptability of appointing foreign managers for national teams reveals a broader debate on national identity in football. Some believe that hiring a foreign manager signals a lack of confidence in domestic coaching talent, while others argue that the priority should be on appointing the best available manager, regardless of nationality. Historical comparisons to other sports and international competitions underscore the tension between traditional norms and the practicalities of winning. This aspect of the debate touches upon what international football represents and how national teams should be managed.
Potential Impact of Tuchel on England's Success
The potential impact of Tuchel's management on England's performance in major tournaments remains a focal point of discussion. While he possesses a strong tactical repertoire, experts caution that international tournament outcomes often hinge more on player management and team dynamics than on innovative strategies. Some analysts express optimism about Tuchel's ability to enhance England's competitiveness based on his experience with high-pressure situations. However, the need for immediate success raises concerns about whether he might prioritize short-term wins over long-term team development.
Jimbo welcomes Rory Smith, Duncan Alexander and Benji Lanyado into the pod after a seismic week in English football.
Thomas Tuchel is the new manager of England. Should the job always go to an English coach? Are tournaments won by the best tactical coaches? And how has this gone down in Germany? Raphael Honigstein has the answer.
The Premier League is back with Tuchel’s old club travelling to leaders Liverpool. Two impressive new managers in Slot and Maresca - who will come out on top?
Elsewhere, Gary O’Neil looks to book himself another spot on Monday Night Football, Brentford look to score from kick-off again and Southampton look to banish those 9-0 demons.
Produced by Charlie Jones.
RUNNING ORDER:
• PART 1a: Tuchel to England - should it happen? (00.45)
• PART 1b: Tuchel to England - will it work? (13.30)
• PART 2: International roundup (26.00)
• PART 3a: Liverpool v Chelsea preview (33.00)
• PART 3b: Wolves v Man City & Bournemouth v Arsenal previews (38.00)
• PART 4a: Tottenham v West Ham & Man Utd v Brentford previews (43.00)
• PART 4b: On This Day & the rest of the PL weekend (53.00)