Jacobin Radio Confronting Capitalism: Why the US Never Got a Labor Party
16 snips
Jan 21, 2026 
Vivek Chibber, a political theorist and editor at Catalyst, discusses the unique challenges faced by the American labor movement. He delves into how American exceptionalism stunted the growth of a labor party, the role of craft unionism versus industrial unionism, and the violent repression that unions faced. Chibber explains how racial tensions and mass immigration complicated solidarity among workers, and he highlights the pivotal changes brought by the New Deal, while questioning its adequacy as a social democratic solution.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
New Deal Created A Limited Welfare State
- The U.S. achieved a limited social democracy during the New Deal with Social Security and union legalization.
- This model delivered rights but remained much weaker than European counterparts due to structural limits.
Union Density Limited Political Power
- U.S. union density peaked far below European levels, limiting labor's political leverage.
- Lower density and no mass labor party locked American social democracy into a weaker form.
Voting Rights Preceded Union Politics
- Early democratization in the U.S. gave white men voting rights before mass unionization.
- That access weakened incentives to form independent labor parties, unlike Europe.
