History Daily Saturday Matinee: American Criminal
Oct 25, 2025
Dive into the chilling tale of a 1958 Halloween murder that unveils a web of marital strife and manipulation. An unsuspecting victim, Peter Fabiano, meets a grim fate when his wife’s friend, along with an accomplice, orchestrates a deadly plan. The gripping narrative reveals a dramatic confession, police mishaps, and sensational media coverage. Discover how cunning relationships and a fateful night led to a shocking crime that left lasting mysteries in its wake.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Masked Visitor Turns Deadly
- On Halloween 1957, Goldeen Pizer waited in a car, donned a mask and red gloves, and rang Peter Fabiano's doorbell before shooting him at close range.
- The shocking act transformed a familiar holiday routine into a moment of lethal violence for a quiet Sun Valley street.
From Marine To Hairstylist
- Peter reinvented himself after WWII by training as a hairstylist and married salon owner Betty Solomon, building a seemingly prosperous life.
- Despite outward success, marital friction emerged around Betty's friendship with Joan Robble, which destabilized their home.
Friendship Sparks Marital Fallout
- Betty's friend Joan Robble actively undermined Peter, provoking arguments that led to Betty briefly leaving him.
- After reconciliation, Peter demanded Betty cut Joan out, but the rift seeded ongoing resentment and suspicion.
