How Can I Trust The Mainstream Media? (with Jon Ward)
Nov 23, 2024
auto_awesome
Jon Ward, a seasoned journalist and author with two decades of experience in American politics and culture, joins the discussion to tackle the alarming decline in trust towards mainstream media. He and the host examine the impact of social media and political isolation on news consumption. They suggest that adopting postures of spectator, student, and servant can help foster a healthier news culture. Ward shares his personal strategies for staying informed and highlights the vital role of local news in rebuilding community engagement.
The significant decline in trust in mainstream media poses a challenge for Christians, as credible news is essential to sharing the gospel.
Political polarization exacerbates distrust in media, creating a fragmented landscape and hindering democratic processes reliant on shared facts.
Supporting established journalistic institutions and diversifying news sources are crucial strategies for fostering a healthier, more informed media consumption mindset.
Deep dives
Decline of Trust in News
The podcast highlights the significant decline in American trust in mass news media, as evidenced by a Gallup survey, which showed trust plummet from 72% in 1976 to only 32% in 2023. This erosion of trust raises concerns for Christians, as the gospel relies on the possibility of reliable news, which is pivotal to conveying good news about Jesus. The birth, death, and resurrection of Christ are historical events that depend on the belief that credible news can exist. If the concept of reliable news deteriorates, it undermines the very foundations of Christian faith and makes it harder to understand and share the gospel.
Political Polarization and News
The podcast delves into how political polarization has further contributed to the decline of trust in news sources, with distinct divides forming along ideological lines. Individuals leaning left generally report trust in mainstream media, while those on the right profoundly distrust it, leading to a fragmented media landscape without shared understandings of facts. This disconnect hampers democratic processes, as collaboration and problem-solving rely on a common set of information and mutual trust. As trust in news deteriorates, individuals may resort to coercive methods for problem-solving, exacerbating societal divides.
Evangelicals and the Concept of News
The relationship between evangelical beliefs and the notion of news is explored, noting that the essence of evangelicalism is rooted in the concept of 'good news.' Historically, the term 'evangelical' is derived from the Greek word 'evangelion,' meaning news, highlighting its significance in the Christian tradition. Through this lens, the gospel intersects with the secular news culture; hence, for the message of the gospel to be understood, a trustworthy news culture is essential. Evangelicals are urged to recognize the importance of a reliable news framework that complements their faith and aids in spreading the gospel.
The Role of Institutions in News
John Ward discusses the importance of understanding and supporting journalistic institutions to restore trust in media. Established news organizations possess a culture of journalistic standards, including fact-checking, editing, and thorough investigation, which set them apart from newer, less-regulated media outlets. Declines in advertisement revenue have strained these traditional institutions, leading to a business model crisis. Despite criticisms of bias in mainstream media, there remains a need for robust journalistic practices that contribute to a healthy democratic society.
Navigating the News Landscape
The conversation emphasizes strategies for individuals to effectively navigate the modern news landscape while fostering civic engagement. People are encouraged to balance their news consumption and become critical readers by diversifying sources to include a mix of established outlets and fresh perspectives. Engaging deeply with specific local issues allows citizens to become informed and active participants in their communities. Ultimately, cultivating a mindset that prioritizes service to others through informed engagement can transform how individuals interact with news, encouraging greater empathy and understanding.
Is it true that “you can’t believe” anything you read? Can we consume news with a mindset other than cynicism, outrage, or fear?
Host Curtis Chang welcomes journalist and author Jon Ward to discuss why Christians need to care about a well-functioning news culture. With an AP poll on mainstream media showing trust at an all-time low, they explore the reasons behind this crisis—political isolation, social media's influence, and potential media bias. Together, they offer a framework for healthy news consumption, focusing on the postures of spectator, student, and servant, while Jon shares his personal strategies for staying informed in a fractured media landscape.